Loading...
The URL can be used to link to this page
Your browser does not support the video tag.
Home
My WebLink
About
PB Packet 2026-10-06
TOWN OF ITHACA PLANNING BOARD Shirley A. Raffensperger Board Room, Town Hall 215 North Tioga Street Ithaca, New York 14850 Tuesday, October 6, 2026 6:30 P.M. AGENDA 1. Persons to be heard. 2. Determination of conformance with the Motion made by the Planning Board at their meeting on September 15, 2026, relative to Town Code § 271-17F(6)(a)[2], specifically regarding the cladding materials associated with the proposed SouthWorks Woods project located off NYS Route 96B/Danby Road, in Town of Ithaca Planned Development Zone No.16. The SouthWorks Woods mixed-income residential project comprises a 6.09-acre portion of the overall SouthWorks (formerly Chain Works District) Redevelopment Project, and involves the construction of eight residential buildings with a total of 130 mixed-income apartments, including a community room, lounge, fitness center, offices, maintenance areas, and storage. The Woods project also involves the development of internal roads and infrastructure, a playground, sidewalk and path connections, stormwater facilities, landscaping, outdoor lighting, parking, and other site improvements. Shift Chainworks Owner 1 LLC, Owner; Beacon Communities, LLC, Applicant; James Gensel, Fagan Engineers & Land Surveyors, PC, Agent. 3. SEQR Determination: Bell Atlantic Mobile Systems, LLC d/b/a Verizon Wireless Personal Wireless Service Facility Project - Ithaca College, 953 Danby Road, 30 College Circle. 4. PUBLIC HEARING: Consideration of Preliminary & Final Site Plan Approval and Special Permit for the proposed Bell Atlantic Mobile Systems, LLC d/b/a Verizon Wireless Personal Wireless Service Facility (PWSF) Project, located on the Ithaca College Campus at 953 Danby Road, and the College Circle Apartments near the Community Center at 30 College Circle. The proposal is a batched PWSF application that includes eight (8) PWSF telecommunications facilities: one (1) macro PWSF on the rooftop of Williams Hall, six (6) small cell PWSFs on decorative poles throughout campus, and one (1) small cell PWSF on the roof of Dillingham Hall. This is an Unlisted Action under the State Environmental Quality Review Act and is subject to an environmental review. Ithaca College, Owner; Jared C. Lusk, Partner, Nixon Peabody, LLP, Applicant/Agent. 5. Approval of Minutes. 6. Other Business. 7. Adjournment. C.J. Randall Director of Planning 607-273-1747 Meeting materials are available at https://townithacany.gov/meeting-calendar-agendas/. The videoconferencing platform ZOOM will also be used for this meeting, and Board Member(s) may attend remotely when authorized by Town policy. The public has the right to attend in person or via videoconferencing and can access ZOOM by the links provided or by going to www.zoom.com/join or calling (929) 436-2866 and entering the Meeting ID# 83643764382. Public comments where applicable can be made in person at the meeting, by USPS to the address above, via the videoconferencin g platform ZOOM, or via email to Planning@townithacany.gov until 3pm the day of the meeting. The email above is also the point of contact for people needing assistance to attend or access the meeting. All comments become a public record and are distributed to Board Members and the Applicant(s) prior to the meeting. The meeting is also broadcast and saved as a courtesy on Youtube.com/@townofithacavideo Town of Ithaca Notice of Public Hearings Planning Board Tuesday, October 6, 2026 @ 6:30 P.M. 215 N. Tioga St. Consideration of Preliminary & Final Site Plan Approval and Special Permit for the proposed Bell Atlantic Mobile Systems, LLC d/b/a Verizon Wireless Personal Wireless Service Facility (PWSF) Project, located on the Ithaca College Campus at 953 Danby Road, and the College Circle Apartments near the Community Center at 30 College Circle. The proposal is a batched PWSF application that includes eight (8) PWSF telecommunications facilities: one (1) macro PWSF on the rooftop of Williams Hall, six (6) small cell PWSFs on decorative poles throughout campus, and one (1) small cell PWSF on the roof of Dillingham Hall. This is an Unlisted Action under the State Environmental Quality Review Act and is subject to an environmental review. Ithaca College, Owner; Jared C. Lusk, Partner, Nixon Peabody, LLP, Applicant/Agent. Meeting materials are available at https://townithacany.gov/meeting-calendar-agendas/. Board Member(s) may attend via the videoconferencing platform ZOOM when necessary. The public can access ZOOM by the links provided or by going to https://us06web.zoom.us or calling (929) 436- 2866 and entering the Meeting ID# 8364 376 4382. Public comments can be made in person at the meeting or via the videoconferencing platform ZOOM above, or by mail, or email to Planning@townithacany.gov until 3pm the day of the meeting. All comments become a public record and are distributed to Board Members and the Applicant(s) prior to the meeting. The meeting is also broadcast and saved as a courtesy on Youtube.com/@townofithacavideo C.J. Randall Director of Planning PROPOSED RESOLUTION: Determination of Conformance- Cladding Materials Motion The Woods at SouthWorks Residential Development NYS Route 96B/Danby Road Tax Parcel No. 40.-3-3 Town of Ithaca Planning Board October 6, 2026 WHEREAS: 1. This action is the determination of conformance with the Motion made by the Planning Board at their meeting on September 15, 2026, relative to Town Code § 271-17F(6)(a)[2], specifically regarding the cladding materials associated with the proposed SouthWorks Woods project located off NYS Route 96B/Danby Road, in Town of Ithaca Planned Development Zone No.16. The SouthWorks Woods mixed-income residential project comprises a 6.09-acre portion of the overall SouthWorks (formerly Chain Works District) Redevelopment Project and involves the construction of eight residential buildings with a total of 130 mixed-income apartments, including a community room, lounge, fitness center, offices, maintenance areas, and storage. The Woods project also involves the development of internal roads and infrastructure, a playground, sidewalk and path connections, stormwater facilities, landscaping, outdoor lighting, parking, and other site improvements. Shift Chainworks Owner 1 LLC, Owner; Beacon Communities, LLC, Applicant; James Gensel, Fagan Engineers & Land Surveyors, PC, Agent; 2. The Planning Board, at the meeting on September 15, 2026, reviewed revised project information regarding architectural cladding materials and façade design and made a Motion to approve the use of only secondary siding materials for 100% of the cladding materials instead of a design that followed the design guidelines outlined in Town Code, §271-17(F)(6)(d), finding that: a. The applicant met the burden of demonstrating why the proposed design was a superior alternative to a design that followed town guidelines, for the reasons set forth in their submittal from SWBR dated August 19, 2026, and b. The industrial nature of the existing site and the apartment buildings' location is set back enough from the residential street context; 3. The Planning Board, at the meeting on September 15, 2026, conditioned approval of the alternative building façade design on the inclusion of a design strategy that breaks up the corrugated siding (using articulation, change of material, revision to the ratio of openings, or similar design strategy within each expanse of corrugated metal) on each of the long facades of the buildings C1, C2, and C3, to meet the desired characteristic of the subarea to have human- scaled details or materials; and 4. The Planning Board, at their meeting on October 6, 2026, has reviewed and accepted as adequate, a set of nine (9) revised undated drawings, prepared by SWBR, with sheets titled “Site Plan-The Woods,” “Imagery-The Woods” (two sheets with Views 1-3), “Exterior Elevations- C1” (two sheets, Before and After), “Exterior Elevations-C2” (two sheets, Before and After), and “Exterior Elevations-C3” (two sheets, Before and After); NOW, THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED: Approval: That the Town of Ithaca Planning Board hereby approves the proposed building designs for Buildings C1, C2, and C3, as shown on the revised undated drawings, prepared by Page 3 Page 2 of 2 SWBR, titled “Imagery-The Woods” (two sheets with Views 1-3), “Exterior Elevations-C1” (two sheets, Before and After), “Exterior Elevations-C2” (two sheets, Before and After), and “Exterior Elevations-C3” (two sheets, Before and After); finding that the proposal complies with the design strategy requested for Buildings C1, C2, and C3, as required in Whereas #3 above. Approval but requires modification-for staff review: That the Town of Ithaca Planning Board hereby approves most of the proposed building designs for Buildings C1, C2, and C3, as shown on the revised undated drawings, prepared by SWBR, titled “Imagery-The Woods” (two sheets with Views 1-3), “Exterior Elevations-C1” (two sheets, Before and After), “Exterior Elevations-C2” (two sheets, Before and After), and “Exterior Elevations-C3” (two sheets, Before and After); finding that the proposal largely complies with the design strategy requested for Buildings C1, C2, and C3, as noted in Whereas #3 above. However, the Applicant shall submit for review and approval by the Director of Planning or their designee, the following additional revisions to Buildings C1, C2, and C3, that show: a. … b. … c. … Denial-requires modification-for PB review: That the Town of Ithaca Planning Board hereby denies the proposed building designs for Buildings C1, C2, and C3, as shown on the revised undated drawings, prepared by SWBR, titled “Imagery-The Woods” (two sheets with Views 1- 3), “Exterior Elevations-C1” (two sheets, Before and After), “Exterior Elevations-C2” (two sheets, Before and After), and “Exterior Elevations-C3” (two sheets, Before and After); finding that the proposal does not comply with the design strategy requested for Buildings C1, C2, and C3, as noted in Whereas #3 above. The Applicant shall submit for Planning Board review revised drawings for Buildings C1, C2, and C3, that show: a. … b. … c. … Page 4 Site Plan - The Woods BR BUILDING A1 BUILDING A2 BUILDING B1 BUILDING B2 BUILDING B3 BUILDING C1 BUILDING C2 BUILDING C3 PLAYGROUND DANBY ROAD MORS E P L A C E RIDE SHARE • • • TEN BIKE RACKS THAT FIT FIVE OR SEVEN BIKES EACH = 66 BIKES ONE CONTROLLED ACCESS BIKE CAGE WITH SEVEN E-BIKE CHARGING SPOTS AND SEVEN REGULAR PARKING SPOTS = 14 BIKES TOTAL = 80 BIKES CAN BE PARKED OUTSIDE ON SITE BIKE PARKING NOTE: SITE PLAN - THE WOODS NSCALE: 1" = 30' 0 30'60'120' NOTE from Town Planning staff: The following pages (9 total) were submitted for the 10/6/26 PB meeting, for consideration of conformance with PB motion made on 9/15/26 relative to cladding materials. Page 5 Imagery - The Woods VIEW 1 VIEW 2 DANBY RD MORSE PLACE N 1 3 2 NOTE from Town Planning staff: This page was submitted for the 10/6/26 PB meeting, for consideration of conformance with PB motion made on 9/15/26 relative to cladding materials. Page 6 Imagery - The Woods VIEW 3 NOTE from Town Planning staff: This page was submitted for the 10/6/26 PB meeting, for consideration of conformance with PB motion made on 9/15/26 relative to cladding materials. Page 7 LINK TO C2 A1 A2 B1 B2 B3 C1 C2 C3 BEACON COMMUNITIES - THE WOODS EXTERIOR ELEVATIONS - C1 1 - FACING ROAD A2 - FACING COURTYARD 3 - FACING DRIVE C 3 1 2 PAC-CLAD 7/8" CORRUGATED PANEL HEMLOCK GREEN JAMES HARDIE BOARD AND BATTEN IMPERIAL GREEN (OR SIMILAR) FINEX PANEL JAMES HARDIE - SMOOTH PANEL LIGHT MIST TRESPA PURA NFC 7" PLANK WESTERN RED CEDAR OMEGA-LITE ACM PANEL COPPERTONE (METALLIC) Exterior Elevations - C1 (43%) BEFORE NOTE from Town Planning staff: This page was submitted for the 10/6/26 PB meeting, for consideration of conformance with PB motion made on 9/15/26 relative to cladding materials. Page 8 LINK TO C2 A1 A2 B1 B2 B3 C1 C2 C3 BEACON COMMUNITIES - THE WOODS EXTERIOR ELEVATIONS - C1 1 - FACING ROAD A2 - FACING COURTYARD 3 - FACING DRIVE C 3 1 2 PAC-CLAD 7/8" CORRUGATED PANEL HEMLOCK GREEN JAMES HARDIE BOARD AND BATTEN IMPERIAL GREEN (OR SIMILAR) FINEX PANEL JAMES HARDIE - SMOOTH PANEL LIGHT MIST TRESPA PURA NFC 7" PLANK WESTERN RED CEDAR OMEGA-LITE ACM PANEL COPPERTONE (METALLIC) Exterior Elevations - C1 (43%) Dropped parapet height Dropped parapet height Vertically connected windows with contrasting light grey panels Trim surround Awning at 1st level windows Vertical trim Contrasting dark green window head trim Wood reveal cuts through copper band Awning at ground level windows facing sidewalk Vertically connected windows with contrasting light grey panels AFTER NOTE from Town Planning staff: This page was submitted for the 10/6/26 PB meeting, for consideration of conformance with PB motion made on 9/15/26 relative to cladding materials. Page 9 LINK TO C3 LINK TO C1 A1 A2 B1 B2 B3 C1 C2 C3 BEACON COMMUNITIES - THE WOODS EXTERIOR ELEVATIONS - C2 1 - FACING ROAD A2 - FACING C3 3 - FACING DRIVE C4 - FACING COURTYARD 3 1 24 PAC-CLAD 7/8" CORRUGATED PANEL HEMLOCK GREEN JAMES HARDIE BOARD AND BATTEN IMPERIAL GREEN (OR SIMILAR)FINEX PANEL JAMES HARDIE - SMOOTH PANEL LIGHT MIST TRESPA PURA NFC 7" PLANK WESTERN RED CEDAR OMEGA-LITE ACM PANEL COPPERTONE (METALLIC) Exterior Elevations - C2 (43%) BEFORE NOTE from Town Planning staff: This page was submitted for the 10/6/26 PB meeting, for consideration of conformance with PB motion made on 9/15/26 relative to cladding materials. Page 10 LINK TO C3 LINK TO C1 A1 A2 B1 B2 B3 C1 C2 C3 BEACON COMMUNITIES - THE WOODS EXTERIOR ELEVATIONS - C2 1 - FACING ROAD A2 - FACING C3 3 - FACING DRIVE C4 - FACING COURTYARD 3 1 24 PAC-CLAD 7/8" CORRUGATED PANEL HEMLOCK GREEN JAMES HARDIE BOARD AND BATTEN IMPERIAL GREEN (OR SIMILAR)FINEX PANEL JAMES HARDIE - SMOOTH PANEL LIGHT MIST TRESPA PURA NFC 7" PLANK WESTERN RED CEDAR OMEGA-LITE ACM PANEL COPPERTONE (METALLIC) Exterior Elevations - C2 (43%) Dropped parapet height Dropped parapet height Vertically connected windows with contrasting light grey panels Trim surround Vertical trim Contrasting dark green window head trim Awning at 1st level windows Wood reveal cuts through copper band Awning at ground level windows facing sidewalk Vertically connected windows with contrasting light grey panels AFTER NOTE from Town Planning staff: This page was submitted for the 10/6/26 PB meeting, for consideration of conformance with PB motion made on 9/15/26 relative to cladding materials. Page 11 LINK TO C2 A1 A2 B1 B2 B3 C1 C2 C3 BEACON COMMUNITIES - THE WOODS EXTERIOR ELEVATIONS - C3 1 - FACING ROAD A2 - SIDE FACING ROUNDABOUT 3 - FACING DRIVE C4 - FACING C2 PAC-CLAD 7/8" CORRUGATED PANEL HEMLOCK GREEN JAMES HARDIE BOARD AND BATTEN IMPERIAL GREEN (OR SIMILAR) FINEX PANEL JAMES HARDIE - SMOOTH PANEL LIGHT MIST OMEGA-LITE ACM PANEL COPPERTONE (METALLIC) 1 23 4 Exterior Elevations - C3 (43%) BEFORE NOTE from Town Planning staff: This page was submitted for the 10/6/26 PB meeting, for consideration of conformance with PB motion made on 9/15/26 relative to cladding materials Page 12 LINK TO C2 A1 A2 B1 B2 B3 C1 C2 C3 BEACON COMMUNITIES - THE WOODS EXTERIOR ELEVATIONS - C3 1 - FACING ROAD A2 - SIDE FACING ROUNDABOUT 3 - FACING DRIVE C4 - FACING C2 PAC-CLAD 7/8" CORRUGATED PANEL HEMLOCK GREEN JAMES HARDIE BOARD AND BATTEN IMPERIAL GREEN (OR SIMILAR) FINEX PANEL JAMES HARDIE - SMOOTH PANEL LIGHT MIST OMEGA-LITE ACM PANEL COPPERTONE (METALLIC) 1 23 4 Exterior Elevations - C3 (43%) Dropped parapet height Dropped parapet height Vertically connected windows with contrasting light grey panels Trim surround Vertical trim Contrasting dark green window head trim Awning at 1st level windows Wood reveal cuts through copper band Awning at ground level windows facing sidewalk Vertically connected windows with contrasting light grey panels AFTER NOTE from Town Planning staff: This page was submitted for the 10/6/26 PB meeting, for consideration of conformance with PB motion made on 9/15/26 relative to cladding materials Page 13 PROPOSED RESOLUTION: SEQR Determination Verizon Wireless- Ithaca College Batched PWSF Project Ithaca College Campus & Circle Apartments Tax Parcel No.’s 41.-1-30.2 & 43.-1-2.2 Planning Board, October 6, 2026 WHEREAS: 1. This action is consideration of Preliminary & Final Site Plan and Special Permit Approval for the proposed Bell Atlantic Mobile Systems, LLC d/b/a Verizon Wireless Personal Wireless Service Facility (PWSF) Project, located on the Ithaca College Campus at 953 Danby Road, and the College Circle Apartments near the Community Center at 30 College Circle. The proposal is a batched PWSF application that includes eight (8) PWSF telecommunication facilities: one (1) macro PWSF array on the rooftop of Williams Hall, six (6) small cell PWSF antennas on decorative poles throughout campus, and one (1) small cell PWSF on the roof of Dillingham Hall. Ithaca College, Owner; Jared C. Lusk, Partner, Nixon Peabody, LLP, Applicant/Agent; 2. This is an Unlisted Action for which the Town of Ithaca Planning Board is acting in an uncoordinated environmental review with respect to the project; 3. The Planning Board, on October 6, 2026, has reviewed and accepted as adequate a completed Short Environmental Assessment Form (SEAF) Part 1, prepared by the applicant; SEAF Parts 2 and 3, prepared by Town Planning staff; application materials dated August 11, 2026, including Exhibits A-Z, along with eight (8) drawing sets prepared by Costitch Engineering, titled as follows: “Bell Atlantic Mobile Systems LLC d/b/a Verizon, Site Name: Ithaca College- Williams Hall Zoning Drawings, Project ID: 17032353, Mdg Location ID: 50000921791,” with sheets GA001-GA002, CA 100-101, CA 110-111, CA 200-201, CA 500-505, RF001, EA 500- 507, most recently revised 6/29/2026; “Verizon Site Name: Ithaca College-02, Project: 4G, Project ID: 17032360, Mdg Location ID: 50000921783, Latitude: 42.425342º (N), Longitude: - 76.491169º (W), Pole No.: New Decorative Pole Set,” with sheets Z1-Z11, most recently revised 08/05/2026; “Verizon Site Name: Ithaca College-03, Project: 4G, Project ID: 17032361, Mdg Location ID: 50000921785, Latitude: 42.420922º (N), Longitude: -76.490636º (W), Pole No.: New Wood Pole Set,” with sheets Z1-Z8, most recently revised 07/29/2026; “Bell Atlantic Mobile Systems LLC d/b/a Verizon, Site Name: Ithaca College-04, Zoning Drawings, Project ID: 17032359, Mdg Location ID: 50000921786,” with sheets GA001-GA002, CA 100-101, CA 110, CA 200-201, CA 500-505, RF001, EA 500-506, most recently revised 6/29/2026; “Verizon Site Name: Ithaca College-05, Project: 4G, Project ID: 17032354, Mdg Location ID: 50000921790, Latitude: 42.419922º (N), Longitude: -76.494811º (W), Pole No.: New Decorative Pole Set,” with sheets Z1-Z12, most recently revised 08/05/2026; “Verizon Site Name: Ithaca College-06, Project: 4G, Project ID: 17032358, Mdg Location ID: 50000921784, Latitude: 42.417714º (N), Longitude: -76.498022º (W), Pole No.: New Decorative Pole Set,” with sheets Z1-Z12, most recently revised 08/05/2026; “Verizon Site Name: Ithaca College-07, Project: 4G, Project ID: 17032357, Mdg Location ID: 50000921777, Latitude: 42.411722º (N), Longitude: -76.500003º (W), Pole No.: New Decorative Pole Set,” with sheets Z1-Z11, most recently revised 08/05/2026; “Verizon Site Name: Ithaca College-08, Project: 4G, Project ID: 17032356, Mdg Location ID: 50000921779, Latitude: 42.418989º (N), Longitude: -76.496969º (W), Pole No.: New Decorative Pole Set,” with sheets Z1-Z120, most recently revised 08/05/2026; and other plans and materials, and Page 16 Page 2 of 2 4. The Town Planning staff has recommended a negative determination of environmental significance with respect to the proposed project; NOW, THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED: That the Town of Ithaca Planning Board hereby makes a negative determination of environmental significance in accordance with Article 8 of the Environmental Conservation Law and 6 NYCRR Part 617 New York State Environmental Quality Review for the above referenced action as proposed, based on the information in the Short EAF Part 1 and for the reasons set forth in the Short EAF Parts 2 and 3, and, therefore, an Environmental Impact Statement will not be required. Page 17 1 To: Planning Board Members From: Christine Balestra, Senior Planner Date: September 29, 2026 RE: Proposed VZW Ithaca College batched PWSF project- Preliminary & Final Site Plan Approval & Special Permit Please find attached materials related to the consideration of Site Plan Approval and Special Permit for the proposed Bell Atlantic Mobile Systems, LLC d/b/a Verizon Wireless Personal Wireless Service Facility (PWSF) Project, located on the Ithaca College Campus at 953 Danby Road, and the College Circle Apartments near the Community Center at 30 College Circle. The proposal is a batched PWSF application that includes eight (8) PWSF telecommunication facilities: one (1) macro PWSF array on the rooftop of Williams Hall, six (6) small cell PWSF s on decorative poles throughout campus, and one 2) small cell PWSF on the roof of Dillingham Hall. The project is located entirely on Ithaca College owned property (campus and Circle apartments, which are owned and managed by Ithaca College). The project requires Site Plan and Special Permit approval by the Planning Board, pursuant to Town Code 270-219. D (5). The board will need to make Special Permit findings per the criteria listed in Town Code 270-200 and 270-219.R (Special Permit criteria specific to PWSFs). The criteria from both sections of Town Code have been enumerated in the draft resolution for the project - that language is listed under the resolved clause numbers “1” and “2” (pages two through five on the attached draft resolution). Also attached is a draft completed environmental assessment (Part 1 completed by the applicant) and draft SEQR resolution for you to consider. Please contact me at (607) 273-1721, ext. 121, or email me at cbalestra@townithacany.gov if you have any questions. Att. Cc: Marc Isreal, Associate VP for Finance & Administration, Ithaca College Jared Lusk, Partner, Nixon Peabody, LLP Ernie McClatchie, Associated VP, Office of Facilities, Ithaca College Page 18 Page 19 Page 20 Page 21 Page 22 Page 23 Page 24 Page 25 Page 26 Page 27 Page 28 Page 29 Page 30 Page 31 Page 32 Page 33 Page 34 Page 35 Page 36 Page 37 Pa g e 3 8 Pa g e 3 9 Pa g e 4 0 Pa g e 4 1 Pa g e 4 2 Pa g e 4 3 Page 44 Page 45 Page 46 Page 47 Page 48 Page 49 Page 50 Page 51 Page 52 Page 53 Page 54 Page 55 Page 56 Page 57 Page 58 Page 59 Page 60 Page 61 Page 62 Page 63 Page 64 Page 65 Page 66 Page 67 Page 68 Page 69 Page 70 Page 71 Page 72 Page 73 Page 74 Page 75 Page 76 Page 77 Page 78 Page 79 Page 80 Page 81 Page 82 Page 83 Page 84 Page 85 Page 86 Page 87 Page 88 Page 89 Page 90 Page 91 Page 92 Page 93 Page 94 Page 95 Page 96 Page 97 Page 98 Page 99 Page 100 Pa g e 1 0 1 Pa g e 1 0 2 Pa g e 1 0 3 Pa g e 1 0 4 Pa g e 1 0 5 Pa g e 1 0 6 Page 107 Page 108 Page 109 Page 110 Page 111 Page 112 Page 113 Page 114 Page 115 Page 116 Page 117 Page 118 Page 119 Page 120 Page 121 Page 122 Page 123 Page 124 Page 125 Page 126 Page 127 Page 128 Page 129 Page 130 Page 131 Page 132 Page 133 Page 134 Page 135 Page 136 Page 137 Page 138 Page 139 Page 140 Page 141 Page 142 Page 143 Page 144 Page 145 Page 146 Page 147 Page 148 Page 149 Page 150 Page 151 Page 152 Page 153 Page 154 Page 155 Page 156 Page 157 Page 158 Page 159 Page 160 Page 161 Pa g e 1 6 2 Pa g e 1 6 3 Pa g e 1 6 4 Pa g e 1 6 5 Pa g e 1 6 6 Pa g e 1 6 7 Page 168 Page 169 Page 170 Page 171 Page 172 Page 173 Page 174 Page 175 Page 176 Page 177 Page 178 Page 179 Page 180 Page 181 Page 182 Page 183 Page 184 Page 185 Page 186 Page 187 Page 188 Page 189 Page 190 Page 191 Page 192 Page 193 Page 194 Page 195 Page 196 Page 197 Page 198 Page 199 Page 200 Page 201 Page 202 Page 203 Page 204 Page 205 Page 206 Page 207 Page 208 Page 209 Page 210 Page 211 Page 212 Page 213 Page 214 Page 215 Page 216 Page 217 Page 218 Page 219 Page 220 Page 221 Pa g e 2 2 2 Pa g e 2 2 3 Pa g e 2 2 4 Pa g e 2 2 5 Pa g e 2 2 6 Pa g e 2 2 7 Page 228 Page 229 Page 230 Page 231 Page 232 Page 233 Page 234 Page 235 Page 236 Page 237 Page 238 Page 239 Page 240 Page 241 Page 242 Page 243 Page 244 Page 245 Page 246 Page 247 Page 248 Page 249 Page 250 Page 251 Page 252 Page 253 Page 254 Page 255 Page 256 Page 257 Page 258 Page 259 Page 260 Page 261 Page 262 Page 263 Page 264 4933-7192-9243.1 MASTER EXHIBITS H-Z Page 265 4933-7192-9243.1 Exhibit H:Project description; Exhibit I:Applicable legal standards; Exhibit J:Proof of Compliance with the Town’s Site Plan Review Requirements, as set forth in Article XXIII of the Code; Exhibit K:Proof of Compliance with the Town’s Special Use Permit Requirements, as set forth in Article XXIV of the Code; Exhibit L:Proof of Compliance with the Town’s Standards for Wireless Telecommunications Facilities, as set forth in § 270-219 of the Code; Exhibit M:Radio Frequency search ring justification (“RF Justification Report”), with propagation studies setting forth the need for the Project; Exhibit N:Site selection report; Exhibit O:Copy of Verizon’s FCC licenses for Tompkins County; Exhibit P:Verizon’s co-location policy; Exhibit Q:Removal letter agreement; Exhibit R:Proof of the land owner’s consent to this Application; Exhibit S:Short Environmental assessment form (“EAF”); Exhibit T:Drive test, walk test and dropped call data; Exhibit U:Required insurance certificates; Exhibit V:Market study report; Exhibit W:Equipment cut sheets; Exhibit X:Certification letter regarding compliance with applicable laws and standards; and Exhibit Y:Letter regarding compliance with applicable federal laws. Page 266 Page 267 4933-7192-9243.1 EXHIBIT H PROJECT DESCRIPTION APPLICATION FOR APPROVAL TO CONSTRUCT AND OPERATE A SERIES OF WIRELESS TELECOMMUNICATIONS FACILITIES TO SERVE ITHACA COLLEGE LOCATED AT 953 DANBY ROAD IN THE TOWN OF ITHACA, NEW YORK. Bell Atlantic Mobile Systems LLC d/b/a Verizon (“Verizon”), a federally licensed wireless telecommunications provider, needs to construct and operate a series of wireless telecommunications facilities (the “Project”) in the Town of Ithaca in order to provide reliable wireless telecommunications service to Ithaca College and the surrounding area. The Projects will be located on the Ithaca College Campus in the Town of Ithaca (the “Site”). Each of the individual projects includes, on behalf of Verizon, requires a special use permit and site plan approval from the Planning Board and several require a setback variance from the Zoning Board of Appeals to construct and operate a telecommunications facility on the campus in order to render adequate and reliable wireless telecommunications service to emergency services, businesses and individuals located within the Ithaca College campus. Wireless telecommunications use has burgeoned since the technology was introduced in the mid-1980s. Wireless technology provides a critical link for emergency services, such as ambulances, which use such service to transmit vital signs and medical information via medical telemetry. Increasingly, police forces are relying on wireless telecommunication devices to communicate with dispatch and receive calls for assistance. Additionally, many businesses heavily rely on wireless telecommunications service, and individuals use it not only for their convenience, but for safety reasons as well. Typically, wireless telecommunication devices operate by transmitting a very low power radio signal between the wireless telecommunication devices and an antenna mounted on a tower, pole, building or other structure. In most instances, the antenna feeds the signal to electronic apparatus housed in a small equipment cabinet near the antenna (the “Base Station”), where it is connected to an ordinary telephone line, and is then routed anywhere in the world. The antennas and Base Station are known as a “macro cell site.” Page 268 - 2 - 4933-7192-9243.1 Because of the low power, a macro cell site is capable of transmitting to and from wireless phones only within a limited geographic area. This limited geographic area is called a “cell.” A macro cell site must be located within a prescribed area in order to provide coverage for the entire cell. Wireless telecommunications technology requires that cells overlap somewhat in order to provide uninterrupted service. When the wireless telecommunications user moves into a new cell, the transmission is automatically transferred to the macro cell site in the new cell. If there is no macro cell site in the new cell, or if the macro cell site in the cell cannot handle the existing user capacity, there will not be reliable wireless telecommunications service in the cell. As high powered macro communications facilities provide network-wide broad coverage, in areas of high intensity usage, a layer of low-powered small cells must be under-laid beneath to create what is termed a Heterogeneous Network (“HetNet”). This network topology is necessary to achieve significantly improved overall network capacity and to ensure that wireless telecommunications service is available to users within cells where there is a high level of user demand. Traditionally, the primary and most effective way to increase capacity is to implement a cell split. A cell split simply refers to adding a second macro cell (either a new tower or rooftop co-location) to provide coverage to the same footprint, effectively splitting the intended coverage area between two macro cells. However, continual cell splitting will yield lower and lower spectral efficiency as inter-cell interference starts to dominate. This is typical for inter-cell distances below ½ mile. Therefore, at short inter-cell distances the more effective way to gain capacity is to deploy micro cells as an underlay. Moreover, in a typical urban/suburban area, data users tend to be concentrated in hotspots rather than evenly distributed throughout. It is, therefore, much more effective to deploy low powered “micro” or “small” cells at these congested hotspots, creating a HetNet, to maximize user signal-to-noise ratio while minimizing interference generated to the macro network or nearby micro cells. Because each macro and micro cell site must be placed in such a manner as to provide service within a particular cell, there is limited flexibility as to where such macro and micro cell sites can be placed. Wireless telecommunications providers conduct a thorough engineering Page 269 - 3 - 4933-7192-9243.1 study, using an elaborate computer program known as a “propagation study.” A propagation study shows, based on cell boundaries, topography and other factors, where a cell site needs to be located in order to provide wireless telecommunications coverage in a particular cell. The wireless telecommunication companies and RF engineers identify technologically feasible locations for the cell site. In this case, the area in and around the Ithaca College campus was identified by Verizon as being an area where there is a high level of user demand in a concentrated area. As set forth in Exhibit M, the Projects are needed in this area to provide adequate capacity offload to the existing macro cell network. Each of the Projects are is located within the targeted coverage area and located at sites that are available to allow Verizon to meet the technological requirements necessary to provide adequate coverage and capacity by constructing each of the Projects. As set forth in this application, Verizon meets the legal standards for receiving the requested zoning approvals to construct and operate the Projects. Moreover, the Projects will not pollute, will not create noise or vibration, will not create any significant increase in traffic, will not create any environmental problems, will not increase population density, and will not create any demand on governmental facilities. Thus, the Projects will not create any detriment to adjoining properties or change the character of the campus on the neighborhood surrounding it. Instead, the Projects will enhance governmental facilities and promote the public welfare by, together, providing a modern, more efficient system of communications for police, fire and other emergency services, as well as provide modern wireless telecommunications service to the campus and surrounding area in the Town. Page 270 Page 271 4933-7192-9243.1 EXHIBIT I APPLICABLE LEGAL STANDARDS In Cellular Tel. Co. v. Rosenberg, 82 N.Y.2d 364 (1993), the New York Court of Appeals determined that cellular telephone companies are public utilities. The Court held that proposed cellular telephone installations are to be reviewed by zoning boards pursuant to the traditional standard afforded to public utilities, rather than the standards generally required for the necessary approvals. ‘It has long been held that a zoning board may not exclude a utility from a community where the utility has shown a need for its facilities.’ There can be no question of Cell One’s need to erect the cell site to eliminate service gaps in its cellular telephone service area. The proposed cell site will also improve the transmission and reception of existing service. Application of our holding in Matter of Consolidated Edison to sitings of cellular telephone companies, such as Cellular One, permits those companies to construct structures necessary for their operation which are prohibited because of existing zoning laws and to provide the desired services to the surrounding community. . . . Moreover, the record supports the conclusion that Cellular One sustained its burden of proving the requisite public necessity. Cellular One established that the erection of the cell site would enable it to remedy gaps in its service area that currently prevent it from providing adequate service to its customers in the Dobbs Ferry area. Rosenberg, 82 N.Y.2d at 372-74 (citing Consolidated Edison Co. v. Hoffman, 43 N.Y.2d 598 (1978)). This special treatment of a public utility stems from the essential nature of its service, and because a public utility transmitting facility must be located in a particular area in order to provide service. For instance, water towers, electric switching stations, water pumping stations and telephone poles must be in particular locations (including within residential districts) in order to provide the utility to a specific area: [Public] utility services are needed in all districts; the service can be provided only if certain facilities (for example, substations) can be located in commercial and even in residential districts. To exclude such use would result in an impairment of an essential service. Page 272 - 2 - 4933-7192-9243.1 Anderson, New York Zoning Law Practice, 4th ed., § 7:12 (2013). See also, Cellular Tel. Co. v. Rosenberg, 82 N.Y.2d 364 (1993); Payne v. Taylor, 178 A.D.2d 979 (4th Dep’t 1991). Accordingly, the law in New York is that a municipality may not prohibit facilities, including towers, necessary for the transmission of a public utility. In Rosenberg, 82 N.Y.2d at 371, the court found that “the construction of an antenna tower . . . to facilitate the supply of cellular telephone service is a ‘public utility building’ within the meaning of a zoning ordinance.” See also Long Island Lighting Co. v. Griffin, 272 A.D. 551 (2d Dep’t 1947) (a municipal corporation may not prohibit the expansion of a public utility where such expansion is necessary to the maintenance of essential services). State and federal courts have applied the standard set forth in Consolidated Edison and Rosenberg to a wide range of telecommunications land use decisions, including use variances,1 area variances,2 special permits,3 and site plans.4 In the present case, Verizon does not have reliable wireless telecommunication coverage in and around its Ithaca College campus, located in the Town of Ithaca. The proposed Projects are needed to remedy this service problem and to provide adequate and reliable wireless telecommunications service coverage to this area. Therefore, Verizon satisfies the requisite showing of need for the facility under applicable New York law. 1 Nextel Partners, Inc. v. Town of Fort Ann, 1 A.D.3d 89, 93 (3rd Dept., 2003) (“There is no question that petitioners are public utilities whose entitlement to a use variance is governed by the ‘public utility’ exception articulated by the Court of Appeals.”) 2 Lloyd v. Town of Greece Zoning Board of Appeals, 292 A.D.2d 818 (4th Dept., 2002), lv. dismissed, lv. denied 98 N.Y.2d 691 (2002) (“As a public utility, AT&T qualifies for the diminished standard of review for its area variance application.”) 3 ExteNet Sys., LLC v. Vill. of Kings Point, 2022 WL 1749200 (E.D.N.Y. 2022) (applying the public utilities standard to a wireless telecommunications provider’s application for a special use permit); Cellco P’ship v. Town of Clifton Park, New York, 365 F. Supp. 3d 248 (N.D.N.Y. 2019) (applying the public utilities standard to a wireless telecommunications provider’s application for a special use permit); Orange County-Poughkeepsie Ltd. Partnership v. Town of E. Fishkill, 84 F. Supp. 3d 274 (S.D.N.Y. 2015), aff’d 632 F. App’x 1 (2d Cir. 2015) (applying the public utilities standard to a wireless telecommunications provider’s application for a special use permit and area variance). 4 Cellular Tel. Co. v. Meyer, 200 A.D.2d 743, 744 (2nd Dept., 1994) (“The Planning Board’s contention that the petitioner is not a public utility entitled to favored status when considering its site plan application is without merit. The Court of Appeals recently held in [Rosenberg], that a cellular telephone company falls within the definition of a public utility.”). Page 273 Page 274 Page 275 Page 276 Page 277 Page 278 Page 279 Page 280 Page 281 Page 282 Page 283 Page 284 Page 285 Page 286 Page 287 Page 288 Page 289 Page 290 Page 291 Page 292 Page 293 Page 294 Page 295 Page 296 Page 297 Page 298 Page 299 Page 300 Page 301 Page 302 Page 303 Page 304 Page 305 Page 306 Page 307 Page 308 Page 309 Page 310 Page 311 Page 312 Page 313 Page 314 Page 315 Page 316 Page 317 Page 318 Page 319 Page 320 Page 321 Page 322 Page 323 Page 324 Page 325 Page 326 Page 327 Page 328 Page 329 Page 330 Page 331 Page 332 Page 333 Page 334 Page 335 Page 336 Page 337 Page 338 Page 339 Page 340 Page 341 Page 342 Page 343 Page 344 Jan 30th, 2026 ITHACA HD Site City/Town Boundary Ithaca College 2 Ithaca College 1 Ithaca College 4 Ithaca College 3 Ithaca College 5 Ithaca College 8 Ithaca College 6 Search Area Ithaca College 7 Danby Road City of Ithaca Town of Ithaca Page 345 2 • • Page 346 3 • Page 347 4 More wireless traffic needs more wireless facilities just like more vehicle traffic needs more lanes. • Many wireless users share each cell site and congestion may result when too many try to use it at the same time. • Wireless coverage may already exist in an area, but with data usage growth increasing exponentially each year, more capacity is needed. • To meet capacity demands, we need to add more sites closer to users and strategically spaced with other cell sites to provide the reliable service customers have come to expect from Verizon. The monthly data traffic in North America is projected to amount to 19.53 exabytes (the equivalent of over four billion DVD’s) by 2027. In 2021, the average data traffic amounted to almost 5 EB per month.* Page 348 5 Page 349 6 • • • Page 350 7 In each graph above,the purple line represents the daily max busy hour Low Band LTE utilization and the dark red line represents the daily max busy hour Mid Band LTE utilization on the Beta sector of the Ithaca site.The red dashed line is the limit where the sector reaches exhaustion and service starts to significantly degrade.The point in time where we see the purple and/or dark red lines reach or exceed the red dashed line is when service quickly degrades as usage continues to increase.Capacity exhaustion can create the same customer experience as a coverage gap. Ideally,capacity relief should be implemented prior to reaching exhausted conditions.In this case the site/sector shown has already exceeded its capability to support one or more of these capacity KPI’s.In order to provide adequate and reliable service to Ithaca College Campus and the surrounding area,network densification is required. Page 351 8 **Dark Green >/= -75dBm RSRP, typically serves dense urban areas as well as areas of substantial construction (colleges, hospitals, dense multi family etc.) Green >/= -85dBm RSRP, typically serves suburban single family residential and light commercial buildings Yellow >/= -95dBm RSRP, typically serves most rural/suburban-residential and in car applications Orange >/= -105dBm RSRP, rural highway coverage, subject to variable conditions including fading and seasonality gaps White = <-105dBm RSRP, variable to no reliable coverage gap area More detailed, site-specific coverage slides are later in the presentation *Signal strength requirements vary as dictated by market and conditions ** Not displayed in example map, layer not used in all site justifications Page 352 9 • • • • To resolve the coverage and capacity deficiencies previously detailed,Verizon Wireless is seeking to add eight new cell facilities within Ithaca College Campus to improve wireless service (coverage/capacity).By providing new dominant signal areas and offloading weak and distant traffic from Ithaca site with the proposed sites,adequate and reliable service will be restored.The new Ithaca College sites will provide dominant and dedicated signal to the identified portions of the College Campus.This helps to improve not only the Ithaca College project areas but will also result with significant improvements to the above mentioned overloaded site ultimately improving community wide areas in and around the Ithaca College project areas. Ithaca College Search Area Page 353 10 The map above represents coverage from existing sites,with the sites in need of capacity offload detailed in the legend above.Blue coverage is from other on air (Low Band)sites. On Air Coverage Ithaca HD Beta Page 354 11 The map above illustrates the coverage footprint of the proposed Ithaca College 1 site,shown in green.The green best-server footprint delivers enhanced coverage and increased capacity across the main campus area,helping to mitigate coverage and capacity constraints impacting the existing overloaded sectors identified above.Ithaca College sites 2 through 8 are small-cell deployments and will not utilize low-band spectrum. On Air Coverage Ithaca HD Beta Ithaca College 1 (Macro) Page 355 12 The map above represents existing low band signal strength coverage from existing sites .Notice the orange coverage areas throughout the college campus that are subject to variable coverage conditions including fading and seasonality gaps. Page 356 13 The map above incorporates the low-band coverage from the Ithaca College 1 site into the existing signal footprint.The resulting increase in signal strength provides enhanced coverage and capacity across the main campus area.Ithaca College sites 2 through 8 are small-cell deployments and will not utilize low-band spectrum. Page 357 14 The map above depicts coverage from existing sites,with sectors requiring capacity offload identified in the legend.Blue shading represents coverage from other on-air mid-band sites.Mid-band coverage across most of the campus area is currently limited or nonexistent,indicating the need for additional mid-band network densification. On Air Coverage Ithaca Beta On Air Coverage Ithaca HD Beta Page 358 On Air Coverage Ithaca HD Beta Ithaca College 1 (Macro) Ithaca College 2-8 (SC) 15 The map above illustrates the addition of the mid-band coverage footprint from the proposed Ithaca College cluster sites,as shown in the legend.The new best-server footprints provide enhanced coverage and increased capacity across previously identified significant gap areas.These improvements enhance service for users within the new best-server regions and help alleviate coverage and capacity constraints affecting the existing overloaded sector identified in the image above. Page 359 16 The map above illustrates mid-band coverage from existing sites.Overall,mid-band coverage across the campus is either nonexistent or very weak.Additional mid-band network densification is required to address these conditions. Page 360 17 The map above incorporates mid-band coverage from the Ithaca College cluster sites into the existing coverage map.The resulting increase in signal strength significantly improves coverage and capacity across previously identified gap areas,helping to resolve coverage and capacity issues affecting portions of the Ithaca College campus. Page 361 18 Wasif Sharif Wasif Sharif Engineer–RF Design 1275 John Street, Suite 100 West Henrietta, NY 14586 585-491-5360 Verizon Wireless The proposed sites resolve the substantial and significant gaps in coverage and capacity impacting this portion of the Ithaca College Campus.These gaps are shown above:The shaded areas represent the gaps in coverage and capacity that the proposed Ithaca College Cluster sites will resolve. Broadway School Pennlaurel Richard St Page 362 19 Page 363 20 Verizon conducted both indoor and outdoor call testing to support this application.The attached file,“OUTDOOR_DRIVE_DATA.csv,”contains detailed outdoor drive-test measurements in tabular form.Slides 21–25 show the corresponding mapped results, highlighting the actual signal strength (RSRP)observed during testing. Indoor testing was performed via walk tests in 12 campus buildings,with the results provided in the attached “WALK DATA -*.csv”files.Slides 26 and 27 present coverage distribution pie charts,illustrating the proportion of measured signal levels across defined coverage tiers. Page 364 21 Page 365 22 Page 366 23 Page 367 24 Page 368 25 Page 369 26 Page 370 27 Page 371 28 Please refer to the attached file,“Failed_Calls.csv,”which contains dropped call and denial-of-service records for the period of January 5 through January 23. In addition,the following slide illustrates the locations of dropped voice connections and Failed Attempt (denial-of-service)recorded between January 5 and January 23.During this timeframe,the call fail rate in the subject area was 3.99%,significantly exceeding the industry-standard call fail metric of 1%.This elevated failure rate underscores the necessity of the proposed sites to address existing coverage and capacity deficiencies in the portions of the Ithaca College. Page 372 29 Page 373 30 Page 374 Page 375 4903-0233-4606.2 Verizon Wireless 1275 John Street, Suite #100 West Henrietta, New York 14586 BELL ATLANTIC MOBILE SYSTEMS LLC d/b/a VERIZON WIRELESS Ithaca College Cluster 953 Danby Rd, Ithaca NY 14850 SITE SELECTION REPORT JULY 6, 2026 Page 376 4903-0233-4606.2 Page 2 of 8 SITE SELECTION REPORT Verizon Wireless proposes to install and operate a cluster of new wireless telecommunication facilities, including a new rooftop Macro, a new rooftop Micro, and six Micro pole sites with associated antennas and equipment and related appurtenances all located on the Ithaca College campus at 953 Danby Rd, Ithaca NY 14850. Personal Wireless Service Facilities are permitted in the Town, upon the issuance of a PWSF permit from the Town’s Director of Code Enforcement, as well as the issuance of a Special Permit and Site Plan Approval from the Planning Board. 1.NEED FOR FACILITY (a) Problem The process of identifying a technologically appropriate location, as well as the need for this communications facility are as provided in the Radio Frequency (“RF”) Engineering Necessity Case report (“RF Justification”) prepared by Verizon Wireless’ RF Design Engineer. As indicated in that report, when a Verizon Wireless RF Engineer identifies coverage gaps in the system or sites that have or will reach data capacity exhaustion or lack of coverage, they issue a “search area” or “search ring”. A search area is a geographical area located within the inadequately serviced area, and it is designed such that if a wireless telecommunications facility is located within the search area, and installed at an appropriate height, it will likely provide the required coverage. For the most part, locations outside of the search area will fail to provide adequate service to the cell. Due to technological constraints and existing topography, there is limited flexibility as to where a new facility can be located and still function properly within the existing wireless network. The goal of the search area is to define the general locations for placement of a cell site that will provide adequate service in the subject cell and work properly as part of the overall network. (b) Solution A search area was developed to address certain network deficiencies identified in the accompanying RF Justification. As shown in Figure 1, the search area encompasses the Ithaca College campus.The search area is depicted by the red shape in Figure 1. The goal of the search area is to define the permissible location for placement of the cell sites that will provide adequate coverage to users of Verizon Wireless’ services in the target cell and also work properly as part of the overall network. Page 377 4903-0233-4606.2 Page 3 of 8 2. SEARCH AREA ANALYSIS (a) Geography & Topography The Ithaca College search area is located on the campus of Ithaca College in the Town of Ithaca. The search area can be identified as a mixture of student housing, faculty buildings, entertainment and sport venues. Topography on the campus is a challenge, ranging from 900’ to 1100’ AMSL north to south across the search area that was also factored into the candidate selection. Figure 1 depicts an overlay of the Search Area. (b) Land Use The Search Area is made up of a mixture of Medium Density Residential and Multiple Residence zones on the Ithaca College campus. Ithaca College serves as hub for educational, cultural, and community involvement for professionals, faculty, staff, students and residents. (c) Description of Figures The following figures are provided to illustrate the different characteristics which exist within the Search Area relative to the identification of a location for a new wireless communications facility. Figure 1 - Depicts the Search Area. Figure 2 – Depicts an overlay of the Search Area with candidates 3. ZONING CONSIDERATIONS (a) Collocation Verizon Wireless routinely seeks to install its antennas and equipment on an existing communication towers or other tall structures, including municipally owned properties (“co- location”), whenever feasible. Local communities universally favor co-location because they can minimize the number of wireless telecommunications towers in an area and many municipalities even provide a streamlined application review process. Co-location is often listed as the highest siting priority in a local municipality’s Zoning Law. In addition to the streamlined zoning application process, co-location is preferred by wireless providers because it is generally a less expensive and more timely option, compared to the installation of a new tower facility. (b)New Structure on Municipally owned Property As its next priority, Verizon Wireless generally seeks to locate wireless telecommunication facilities on municipally owned property. These locations are often preferred by municipalities as the Page 378 4903-0233-4606.2 Page 4 of 8 second preference behind co-location as it allows municipalities to benefit from a rental stream for the leased premises. There weren’t any municipal owned properties within the search area for consideration. (c) New Structure on Privately-owned Property When it is not feasible to co-locate on an existing tower or tall structure, Verizon Wireless must find an appropriate site that can accommodate a new communications structure. In doing so, the Site Acquisition Specialist attempts to identify properties in the search area large enough to accommodate the facility and any required bulk area requirements such as set back and fall zones that may exist in the local zoning law. In addition, other characteristics such as existing compatible land use and existing mature vegetation that can screen the facility are considered. Access, land use, the presence of wetlands, floodplains and other contributing factors are also examined, as well as construction-related issues. 4. CANDIDATE/ALTERNATIVES ANALYSIS Unfortunately, there are no suitable towers in the search area viable for the installation of Verizon Wireless’ antennas and equipment. The primary objective of the Ithaca College Cluster Project is to provide dedicated and reliable Indoor and Outdoor coverage for the campus. A thorough engineering analysis was conducted to determine if the existing Emergency Tower located within the Ithaca College Natural Lands at 953 Danby Rd could be utilized. The results confirm that utilizing this tower would fail to meet project goals and would negatively impact the City's existing wireless coverage. Key Findings & Justification 1. Mitigation of Urban Signal Interference The Emergency Tower is situated on a hill at a ground elevation of 1,135 ft, while the City Downtown sits below 500 ft. The Problem: Due to its extreme height, antennas on this tower would "overlook" the entire city, causing the signal to "overshoot" the campus and bleed into the downtown core. The Impact: This creates significant interference with existing Verizon towers, effectively doing "more harm than good" by degrading service for residents and businesses in the downtown area. Page 379 4903-0233-4606.2 Page 5 of 8 2. Strategic Spectrum Reuse and Capacity Wireless capacity is a finite resource. To serve a high-density environment like a college campus, the network must be designed for Spectrum Reuse. Geometric Inefficiency: The Emergency Tower is not centrally located relative to the campus. This placement would result in one sector being "over-utilized" (congested), while others remain under-utilized. The Multi-Site Advantage: Our proposed solution utilizes multiple sites kept under 50 ft. These lower heights prevent the signal from traveling too far, allowing us to reuse the same frequencies at different campus locations. This provides significantly more data capacity with far less interference. 3. Necessity of Proximity for Indoor Penetration A critical requirement for this project is ensuring reliable coverage inside campus buildings (classrooms, dormitories, and labs). Signal Decay: Modern building materials (concrete, steel, and energy-efficient glass) act as shields. A signal originating from a distant hilltop tower loses its "penetration power" before it even reaches the campus. The Proposed Solution: By placing smaller sites closer to the campus buildings, we ensure the signal source is near enough to penetrate building envelopes, providing the high-quality indoor service that students and faculty require. Conclusion The above-mentioned technical constraints rule out the Emergency Tower as a viable location. Proceeding with the Multiple Site Solution is necessary to ensure reliable Indoor/Outdoor coverage for Ithaca College and to protect the city's existing network. Verizon Wireless met with the leadership group of Ithaca College to identify the areas lacking adequate coverage. Input from Ithaca College leadership, Verizon Wireless’ network evaluation, which included indoor walk testing and outdoor drive testing and dropped call data, were used to identify the best viable solution for the inadequate coverage. After carefully investigating the structures within the Search Area, the Williams Hall building was identified as a primary location for a rooftop Macro due to its central location on the campus. Page 380 4903-0233-4606.2 Page 6 of 8 The Macro would be supported by seven additional Micro facilities proposed in specific locations to fill the coverage gaps they were identified. The proposed wireless facility locations are identified in Figure 2. 5. SUMMARY After canvassing this Search Area, it was determined that a total of eight wireless facilities were needed to provide the coverage and capacity relief in the Ithaca College campus area. The RF Engineer has carefully identified the specific locations where the facilities are being proposed. These wireless facilities are intended to provide increased wireless telecommunications coverage in an area where Verizon Wireless’ existing macro cell network is overburdened by demand and is lacking coverage for its 4th Generation LTE Network. Thank you, Nico Facey Project Manager NETWORK BUILDING + CONSULTING Page 381 4903-0233-4606.2 Page 7 of 8 FIGURE 1 Verizon Wireless Ithaca College Search Area Page 382 4903-0233-4606.2 Page 8 of 8 FIGURE 2 Verizon Wireless Ithaca College Search Area with Candidates Page 383 Page 384 Page 385 Page 386 Page 387 Page 388 Page 389 Page 390 Page 391 Page 392 Page 393 Page 394 Page 395 Page 396 Page 397 Page 398 Page 399 Page 400 Page 401 Page 402 Page 403 Page 404 Page 405 Page 406 Page 407 Page 408 Page 409 Page 410 Page 411 Page 412 Page 413 Page 414 Page 415 Page 416 Page 417 Page 418 Page 419 Page 420 Page 421 Page 422 Page 423 Page 424 Page 425 Page 426 Page 427 Page 428 Page 429 Page 430 Page 431 Page 432 Page 433 Page 434 Page 435 Page 436 Page 437 Page 438 Page 439 Page 440 Page 441 Page 442 Page 443 Page 444 Page 445 Page 446 Page 447 Page 448 Page 449 Page 450 Page 451 Page 452 Page 453 Page 454 Page 455 Page 456 Page 457 Page 458 Page 459 Page 460 Page 461 Page 462 Page 463 Page 464 Page 465 Page 466 Page 467 Page 468 Page 469 Page 470 Page 471 Page 472 Page 473 Page 474 Page 475 Page 476 Page 477 Page 478 Page 479 Page 480 Page 481 Page 482 Page 483 Page 484 Page 485 Page 486 Page 487 Page 488 Page 489 Page 490 Page 491 Page 492 Page 493 Page 494 Page 495 Page 496 Page 497 Page 498 Page 499 Page 500 Page 501 Page 502 Page 503 Page 504 Page 505 Page 506 Page 507 Page 508 Page 509 Page 510 Page 511 Page 512 Page 513 Page 514 Page 515 Page 516 Page 517 Page 518 Page 519 Page 520 Page 521 Page 522 Page 523 Page 524 Page 525 Page 526 Page 527 Page 528 Page 529 Page 530 Page 531 Page 532 Page 533 Page 534 Page 535 Page 536 Page 537 Page 538 Page 539 Page 540 Page 541 Page 542 Page 543 Page 544 Page 545 Page 546 Page 547 Page 548 Page 549 Page 550 Verizon Wireless Ithaca College (7) Small Cell Deployments: (5) Decorative Poles, (1) Wood Pole, (1) Rooftop Small Cell Ithaca College 02: New decorative pole set near Garden Apartments, 953 Danby Rd, Ithaca, NY 14850 (T.A.# 41.-1-30.2 / 588.22 acres per tax map) Bell Atlantic Mobile Systems, LLC d/b/a Verizon Wireless is proposing the installation of a new 25.42'± AGL decorative pole. A top- mounted Cantenna will be installed with an antenna centerline of 28'± AGL and an overall antenna height of 29'± AGL. The proposal also includes an equipment cabinet mounted at 10' AGL (bottom of cabinet) to house (2) radios and (2) Delta Power Supply Units, as well as associated electric, fiber, and cable routing infrastructure and ground rods with conductors. Ithaca College 03: New wood pole set near: Boothroyd Hall Building - 953 Danby Rd, Ithaca, NY 14850 (T.A.# 41.-1-30.2 / 588.22 acres per tax map) Bell Atlantic Mobile Systems, LLC d/b/a Verizon Wireless is proposing the installation of a new 35'± AGL wood pole, to be cut down to 25.4'± AGL. A top-mounted panel antenna will be installed with an antenna centerline of 28'± AGL and an overall antenna height of 29'± AGL. The proposal also includes an equipment cabinet mounted at 10' AGL (bottom of cabinet) to house (2) radios and (2) Delta Power Supply Units, as well as associated electric, fiber, and cable routing infrastructure and ground rods with conductors. Ithaca College 04: Rooftop small cell installation at 953 Danby Rd, Ithaca, New York, 14850, Town of Ithaca, Tomkins County (T.A.# 41.-1-30.2 / 588.22 Acres per tax map) Proposed placement of Bell Atlantic Mobile Systems, LLC d/b/a Verizon Wireless antennas on the existing Dillingham Center building rooftop located on the Ithaca College campus. Work includes (1) exterior rooftop 6' x 6' (36± sq. ft.) antenna lease area for a proposed 5' x 5' Rohn non-penetrating roof mount and associated equipment, with an ACL of 43.6'± and an overall antenna height of 44.6'± AGL. Additional work includes a Bell Atlantic Mobile Systems, LLC d/b/a Verizon Wireless rooftop equipment lease area measuring 8' x 6' (48± sq. ft.) to house a proposed 5' x 7' CommScope equipment platform and associated equipment. Ithaca College 05: New decorative pole set near: Terrace 3 Building - 953 Danby Rd, Ithaca, NY 14850 (TA# 41.-1-30.2 / 588.22 acres per tax map) Bell Atlantic Mobile Systems, LLC d/b/a Verizon Wireless is proposing the installation of a new 25.42'± AGL decorative pole. A top- mounted Cantenna will be installed with an antenna centerline of 28'± AGL and an overall antenna height of 29'± AGL. The proposal also includes an equipment cabinet mounted at 10' AGL (bottom of cabinet) to house (2) radios and (2) Delta Power Supply units, as well as associated electric, fiber, and cable routing infrastructure and ground rods with conductors. Ithaca College 06: New decorative pole set near: Terrace 13 Building - 953 Danby Rd, Ithaca, NY 14850 (TA# 41.-1-30.2 / 588.22 acres per tax map) Bell Atlantic Mobile Systems, LLC d/b/a Verizon Wireless is proposing the installation of a new 31.5'± AGL decorative pole. A top- mounted Cantenna will be installed with an antenna centerline of 34'± AGL and an overall antenna height of 35'± AGL. The proposal also includes an equipment cabinet mounted at 10' AGL (bottom of cabinet) to house (2) radios and (2) Delta Power Supply units, as well as associated electric, fiber, and cable routing infrastructure and ground rods with conductors. Ithaca College 07: New decorative pole set near: Circles Community Center- 30 College Circle, Ithaca, NY 14850 (TA# 43.-1-2.2 / 30.5 acres per tax map) Bell Atlantic Mobile Systems, LLC d/b/a Verizon Wireless is proposing the installation of a new 42.42'± AGL decorative pole. A top- mounted Cantenna will be installed with an antenna centerline of 45'± AGL and an overall antenna height of 46'± AGL. The proposal also includes an equipment cabinet mounted at 10' AGL (bottom of cabinet) to house (2) radios and (2) Delta Power Supply units, as well as associated electric, fiber, and cable routing infrastructure and ground rods with conductors. Ithaca College 08: New decorative pole set near: Terrace 6 Building - 104 Flora Brown Dr, Ithaca, NY 14850 (TA# 41.-1-30.2 / 588.22 acres per tax map) Bell Atlantic Mobile Systems, LLC d/b/a Verizon Wireless is proposing the installation of a new 25.42'± AGL decorative pole. A top- mounted Cantenna will be installed, with an antenna centerline of 28'± AGL and an overall height of 29'± AGL. The proposal also includes an equipment cabinet at 10 feet AGL (bottom of cabinet) to house (2) radios and (2) Delta Power Supply units, as well as the installation of electric, fiber, and cable routing infrastructure, and ground rods with conductors. NOTE TO PLANNING BOARD: This sheet is attached to the Short EAF Part 1. Town staff made extra copies and duplicated it in the front of the packet, attached to the site plan, for ease of reference. Page 551 Page 552 PROPOSED RESOLUTION: SEQR Determination Verizon Wireless- Ithaca College Batched PWSF Project Ithaca College Campus & Circle Apartments Tax Parcel No.’s 41.-1-30.2 & 43.-1-2.2 Planning Board, October 6, 2026 WHEREAS: 1. This action is consideration of Preliminary & Final Site Plan and Special Permit Approval for the proposed Bell Atlantic Mobile Systems, LLC d/b/a Verizon Wireless Personal Wireless Service Facility (PWSF) Project, located on the Ithaca College Campus at 953 Danby Road, and the College Circle Apartments near the Community Center at 30 College Circle. The proposal is a batched PWSF application that includes eight (8) PWSF telecommunication facilities: one (1) macro PWSF array on the rooftop of Williams Hall, six (6) small cell PWSF antennas on decorative poles throughout campus, and one (1) small cell PWSF on the roof of Dillingham Hall. Ithaca College, Owner; Jared C. Lusk, Partner, Nixon Peabody, LLP, Applicant/Agent; 2. This is an Unlisted Action for which the Town of Ithaca Planning Board is acting in an uncoordinated environmental review with respect to the project; 3. The Planning Board, on October 6, 2026, has reviewed and accepted as adequate a completed Short Environmental Assessment Form (SEAF) Part 1, prepared by the applicant; SEAF Parts 2 and 3, prepared by Town Planning staff; application materials dated August 11, 2026, including Exhibits A-Z, along with eight (8) drawing sets prepared by Costitch Engineering, titled as follows: “Bell Atlantic Mobile Systems LLC d/b/a Verizon, Site Name: Ithaca College- Williams Hall Zoning Drawings, Project ID: 17032353, Mdg Location ID: 50000921791,” with sheets GA001-GA002, CA 100-101, CA 110-111, CA 200-201, CA 500-505, RF001, EA 500- 507, most recently revised 6/29/2026; “Verizon Site Name: Ithaca College-02, Project: 4G, Project ID: 17032360, Mdg Location ID: 50000921783, Latitude: 42.425342º (N), Longitude: - 76.491169º (W), Pole No.: New Decorative Pole Set,” with sheets Z1-Z11, most recently revised 08/05/2026; “Verizon Site Name: Ithaca College-03, Project: 4G, Project ID: 17032361, Mdg Location ID: 50000921785, Latitude: 42.420922º (N), Longitude: -76.490636º (W), Pole No.: New Wood Pole Set,” with sheets Z1-Z8, most recently revised 07/29/2026; “Bell Atlantic Mobile Systems LLC d/b/a Verizon, Site Name: Ithaca College-04, Zoning Drawings, Project ID: 17032359, Mdg Location ID: 50000921786,” with sheets GA001-GA002, CA 100-101, CA 110, CA 200-201, CA 500-505, RF001, EA 500-506, most recently revised 6/29/2026; “Verizon Site Name: Ithaca College-05, Project: 4G, Project ID: 17032354, Mdg Location ID: 50000921790, Latitude: 42.419922º (N), Longitude: -76.494811º (W), Pole No.: New Decorative Pole Set,” with sheets Z1-Z12, most recently revised 08/05/2026; “Verizon Site Name: Ithaca College-06, Project: 4G, Project ID: 17032358, Mdg Location ID: 50000921784, Latitude: 42.417714º (N), Longitude: -76.498022º (W), Pole No.: New Decorative Pole Set,” with sheets Z1-Z12, most recently revised 08/05/2026; “Verizon Site Name: Ithaca College-07, Project: 4G, Project ID: 17032357, Mdg Location ID: 50000921777, Latitude: 42.411722º (N), Longitude: -76.500003º (W), Pole No.: New Decorative Pole Set,” with sheets Z1-Z11, most recently revised 08/05/2026; “Verizon Site Name: Ithaca College-08, Project: 4G, Project ID: 17032356, Mdg Location ID: 50000921779, Latitude: 42.418989º (N), Longitude: -76.496969º (W), Pole No.: New Decorative Pole Set,” with sheets Z1-Z120, most recently revised 08/05/2026; and other plans and materials, and Page 553 Page 2 of 2 4. The Town Planning staff has recommended a negative determination of environmental significance with respect to the proposed project; NOW, THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED: That the Town of Ithaca Planning Board hereby makes a negative determination of environmental significance in accordance with Article 8 of the Environmental Conservation Law and 6 NYCRR Part 617 New York State Environmental Quality Review for the above referenced action as proposed, based on the information in the Short EAF Part 1 and for the reasons set forth in the Short EAF Parts 2 and 3, and, therefore, an Environmental Impact Statement will not be required. Page 554 □ Short Environmental Assessment Form Part 1 - Project Information Instructions for Completing Part 1 – Project Information. The applicant or project sponsor is responsible for the completion of Part 1. Responses become part of the application for approval or funding, are subject to public review, and may be subject to further verification. Complete Part 1 based on information currently available. If additional research or investigation would be needed to fully respond to any item, please answer as thoroughly as possible based on current information. Complete all items in Part 1. You may also provide any additional information you believe will be needed by or useful to the lead agency; attach additional pages as necessary to supplement any item. Part 1 – Project and Sponsor Information Name of Action or Project: Project Location (describe, and attach a location map): Brief Description of Proposed Action: Name of Applicant or Sponsor: Telephone: E-Mai Address: City/PO: State: Zip Code: 1. Does the proposed action only involve the legislative adoption of a plan, local law, ordinance, administrative rule, or regulation? If Yes, attach a narrative description of the intent of the proposed action and the environmental resources that may be affected in the municipality and proceed to Part 2. If No, continue to question 2. NO YES 2. Does the proposed action require a permit, approval or funding from any other government Agency? If Yes, list agency(s) name and permit or approval: NO YES 3. a. Total acreage of the site of the proposed action? acres b. Total acreage to be physically disturbed? acres c. Total acreage (project site and any contiguous properties) owned or controlled by the applicant or project sponsor? acres 4. Check all land uses that occur on, are adjoining or near the proposed action: Urban Rural (non-agriculture) Industrial Commercial Residential (suburban) Forest Agriculture Aquatic Other(Specify): Parkland Page 1 of 3 SEAF 2026 Page 555 SEAF 2026Page 2 of 3 5.Is the proposed action, a.A permitted use under the zoning regulations? b.Consistent with the adopted comprehensive plan? NO YES N/A 6.Is the proposed action consistent with the predominant character of the existing built or natural landscape?NO YES 7.Is the site of the proposed action located in, or does it adjoin, a state listed Critical Environmental Area? If Yes, identify: NO YES c.Are any pedestrian accommodations or bicycle routes available on or near the site of the proposed action? NO YES 9. Does the proposed action meet or exceed the state energy code requirements?NO YES 10. Will If the proposed action will exceed requirements, describe design features and technologies: the proposed action connect to an existing public/private water supply? If No, describe method for providing potable water: NO YES 11. Will the proposed action connect to existing wastewater utilities? If No, describe method for providing wastewater treatment: NO YES 12. a. Does the project site contain, or is it substantially contiguous to, a building, archaeological site, or district which is listed on the National or State Register of Historic Places, or that has been determined by the Commissioner of the NYS Office of Parks, Recreation and Historic Preservation to be eligible for listing on the State Register of Historic Places? b.Is the project site, or any portion of it, located in or adjacent to an area designated as sensitive for archaeological sites on the NY State Historic Preservation Office (SHPO) archaeological site inventory? NO YES 13.a. Does any portion of the site of the proposed action, or lands adjoining the proposed action, contain wetlands or other waterbodies regulated by a federal, state or local agency? b.Would the proposed action physically alter, or encroach into, any existing wetland or waterbody? If Yes, identify the wetland or waterbody and extent of alterations in square feet or acres: NO YES 8.a. Will the proposed action result in a substantial increase in traffic above present levels? b.Are public transportation services available at or near the site of the proposed action? Area is served by TCAT Routes 11 & 65 Multiple paths and trails connect IC campus to Circle Apts to sidewalks along both entrances of Ithaca College to Danby Road and Coddington Road, and to the South Hill RecWay off Coddington Road. Please see Part 3 Page 556 Please see Part 3 Pa g e 5 5 7 EAF Mapper Summary Report Wednesday, August 26, 2026 2:45 PM Disclaimer: The EAF Mapper is a screening tool intended to assist project sponsors and reviewing agencies in preparing an environmental assessment form (EAF). Not all questions asked in the EAF are answered by the EAF Mapper. Additional information on any EAF question can be obtained by consulting the EAF Workbooks. Although the EAF Mapper provides the most up-to-date digital data available to DEC, you may also need to contact local or other data sources to confirm data provided by the Mapper or to obtain data not provided by the Mapper. Part 1 / Question 7 [Critical Environmental Area] No Part 1 / Question 12a [National or State Register of Historic Places or State Eligible Sites] No Part 1 / Question 12b [Archeological Sites]No Part 1 / Question 13a [Wetlands or Other Regulated Waterbodies] Yes - Digital mapping information on local, New York State, and federal wetlands and waterbodies is known to be incomplete. Refer to the EAF Workbook. Part 1 / Question 15 [Threatened or Endangered Animal] No Part 1 / Question 16 [100 or 500 Year Floodplain] Digital mapping data are not available or are incomplete. Refer to EAF Workbook. Part 1 / Question 20 [Remediation Site]Yes Part 1 / Question 21 [Disadvantaged Community] No 1Short Environmental Assessment Form - EAF Mapper Summary Report Page 558 Verizon Wireless Ithaca College (7) Small Cell Deployments: (5) Decorative Poles, (1) Wood Pole, (1) Rooftop Small Cell Ithaca College 02: New decorative pole set near Garden Apartments, 953 Danby Rd, Ithaca, NY 14850 (T.A.# 41.-1-30.2 / 588.22 acres per tax map) Bell Atlantic Mobile Systems, LLC d/b/a Verizon Wireless is proposing the installation of a new 25.42'± AGL decorative pole. A top- mounted Cantenna will be installed with an antenna centerline of 28'± AGL and an overall antenna height of 29'± AGL. The proposal also includes an equipment cabinet mounted at 10' AGL (bottom of cabinet) to house (2) radios and (2) Delta Power Supply Units, as well as associated electric, fiber, and cable routing infrastructure and ground rods with conductors. Ithaca College 03: New wood pole set near: Boothroyd Hall Building - 953 Danby Rd, Ithaca, NY 14850 (T.A.# 41.-1-30.2 / 588.22 acres per tax map) Bell Atlantic Mobile Systems, LLC d/b/a Verizon Wireless is proposing the installation of a new 35'± AGL wood pole, to be cut down to 25.4'± AGL. A top-mounted panel antenna will be installed with an antenna centerline of 28'± AGL and an overall antenna height of 29'± AGL. The proposal also includes an equipment cabinet mounted at 10' AGL (bottom of cabinet) to house (2) radios and (2) Delta Power Supply Units, as well as associated electric, fiber, and cable routing infrastructure and ground rods with conductors. Ithaca College 04: Rooftop small cell installation at 953 Danby Rd, Ithaca, New York, 14850, Town of Ithaca, Tomkins County (T.A.# 41.-1-30.2 / 588.22 Acres per tax map) Proposed placement of two Bell Atlantic Mobile Systems, LLC d/b/a Verizon Wireless antennas on the existing Dillingham Center building rooftop located on the Ithaca College campus. Work includes (1) exterior rooftop 6' x 6' (36± sq. ft.) antenna lease area for a proposed 5' x 5' Rohn non-penetrating roof mount and associated equipment, with an ACL of 43.6'± and an overall antenna height of 44.6'± AGL. Additional work includes a Bell Atlantic Mobile Systems, LLC d/b/a Verizon Wireless rooftop equipment lease area measuring 8' x 6' (48± sq. ft.) to house a proposed 5' x 7' CommScope equipment platform and associated equipment. Ithaca College 05: New decorative pole set near: Terrace 3 Building - 953 Danby Rd, Ithaca, NY 14850 (TA# 41.-1-30.2 / 588.22 acres per tax map) Bell Atlantic Mobile Systems, LLC d/b/a Verizon Wireless is proposing the installation of a new 25.42'± AGL decorative pole. A top- mounted Cantenna will be installed with an antenna centerline of 28'± AGL and an overall antenna height of 29'± AGL. The proposal also includes an equipment cabinet mounted at 10' AGL (bottom of cabinet) to house (2) radios and (2) Delta Power Supply units, as well as associated electric, fiber, and cable routing infrastructure and ground rods with conductors. Ithaca College 06: New decorative pole set near: Terrace 13 Building - 953 Danby Rd, Ithaca, NY 14850 (TA# 41.-1-30.2 / 588.22 acres per tax map) Bell Atlantic Mobile Systems, LLC d/b/a Verizon Wireless is proposing the installation of a new 31.5'± AGL decorative pole. A top- mounted Cantenna will be installed with an antenna centerline of 34'± AGL and an overall antenna height of 35'± AGL. The proposal also includes an equipment cabinet mounted at 10' AGL (bottom of cabinet) to house (2) radios and (2) Delta Power Supply units, as well as associated electric, fiber, and cable routing infrastructure and ground rods with conductors. Ithaca College 07: New decorative pole set near: Circles Community Center- 30 College Circle, Ithaca, NY 14850 (TA# 43.-1-2.2 / 30.5 acres per tax map) Bell Atlantic Mobile Systems, LLC d/b/a Verizon Wireless is proposing the installation of a new 42.42'± AGL decorative pole. A top- mounted Cantenna will be installed with an antenna centerline of 45'± AGL and an overall antenna height of 46'± AGL. The proposal also includes an equipment cabinet mounted at 10' AGL (bottom of cabinet) to house (2) radios and (2) Delta Power Supply units, as well as associated electric, fiber, and cable routing infrastructure and ground rods with conductors. Ithaca College 08: New decorative pole set near: Terrace 6 Building - 104 Flora Brown Dr, Ithaca, NY 14850 (TA# 41.-1-30.2 / 588.22 acres per tax map) Bell Atlantic Mobile Systems, LLC d/b/a Verizon Wireless is proposing the installation of a new 25.42'± AGL decorative pole. A top- mounted Cantenna will be installed, with an antenna centerline of 28'± AGL and an overall height of 29'± AGL. The proposal also includes an equipment cabinet at 10 feet AGL (bottom of cabinet) to house (2) radios and (2) Delta Power Supply units, as well as the installation of electric, fiber, and cable routing infrastructure, and ground rods with conductors. Page 559 Short Environmental Assessment Form Part 2 - Impact Assessment Agency Use Only [If applicable] Project: Date: Part 2 is to be completed by the Lead Agency. Answer all of the following questions in Part 2 using the information contained in Part 1 and other materials submitted by the project sponsor or otherwise available to the reviewer. When answering the questions the reviewer should be guided by the concept “Have my responses been reasonable considering the scale and context of the proposed action?” No, or small impact may occur Moderate to large impact may occur 1. Will the proposed action create a material conflict with an adopted land use plan or zoning regulations? 2. Will the proposed action result in a change in the use or intensity of use of land? 3. Will the proposed action impair the character or quality of the existing community? 4. Will the proposed action have an impact on the environmental characteristics that caused the establishment of a Critical Environmental Area (CEA)? 5. Will the proposed action result in an adverse change in the existing level of traffic or affect existing infrastructure for mass transit, biking or walkway? 6. Will the proposed action cause an increase in the use of energy and it fails to incorporate reasonably available energy conservation or renewable energy opportunities? 7. Will the proposed action impact existing: a. public / private water supplies? b. public / private wastewater treatment utilities? 8. Will the proposed action impair the character or quality of important historic, archaeological, architectural or aesthetic resources? 9. Will the proposed action result in an adverse change to natural resources (e.g., wetlands, waterbodies, groundwater, air quality, flora and fauna)? 10. Will the proposed action result in an increase in the potential for erosion, flooding or drainage problems? 11. Will the proposed action create a hazard to environmental resources or human health? 12. Is the potentially affected disadvantaged community identified as having comparatively higher burdens or vulnerabilities by the Disadvantaged Community Assessment Tool (https://on.ny.gov/DACAT)? 13. Will the proposed action cause or increase a pollution burden within a disadvantaged community? Page 1 of 2 SEAF 2026 VZW Batched PWSF-IC Campus October 6, 2026 Page 560 Agency Use Only [If applicable] Project: Date: Page 2 of 2 Check this box if you have determined, based on the information and analysis above, and any supporting documentation, that the proposed action may result in one or more potentially large or significant adverse impacts and an environmental impact statement is required. Check this box if you have determined, based on the information and analysis above, and any supporting documentation, that the proposed action will not result in any significant adverse environmental impacts. Name of Lead Agency Date Print or Type Name of Responsible Officer in Lead Agency Title of Responsible Officer Signature of Responsible Officer in Lead Agency Signature of Preparer (if different from Responsible Officer) VZW Batched PWSF-IC Campus October 6, 2026 Short Environmental Assessment Form Part 3 Determination of Significance For every question in Part 2 that was answered “moderate to large impact may occur,” or if there is a need to explain why a particular element of the proposed action may or will not result in a significant adverse environmental impact, please complete Part 3. Part 3 should, in sufficient detail, identify the impact, including any measures or design elements that have been included by the project sponsor to avoid or reduce impacts. Part 3 should also explain how the lead agency determined that the impact may or will not be significant. Each potential impact should be assessed considering its setting, probability of occurring, duration, irreversibility, geographic scope and magnitude. Also consider the potential for short- term, long-term and cumulative impacts. The proposal includes the installation of eight (8) Personal Wireless Service Facilities (PWSF), located on the Ithaca College campus and Circle Apartments. The project is intended to serve the Ithaca College campus community and address significant coverage gaps on and around the campus. Two (2) PWSFs involve antennas on the rooftop of buildings- "Williams Hall" macro installation (12 total antennas) and "Ithaca 04- Dillingham Hall" small-cell antenna installation (2 total antennas). The remaining six (6) PWSFs are single small-cell antennas on poles throughout campus. The Williams Hall rooftop PWSF macro antenna array has been designed to blend in and match the colors of the building on which it is placed. All equipment will be located inside the building, so there will be no anticipated visual or noise impacts. The building is in the middle of campus, and is not near or within any scenic viewsheds. The closest residential property is located more than 1400 feet north east of proposed facility. This respective part of the project complies with all Town Code provisions; no variances are required. The Ithaca-04 Dillingham small cell installation is also designed to match the colors of the existing building. The antennas will be visible on the roof, but the installation is much smaller than the macro on Williams and is not near or within any scenic viewsheds. All proposed equipment will be hidden behind much larger existing mechanicals/building features. The closest residential property is over 1400 feet south east of the proposed facility. The respective part of the project complies with all Town Code provisions; no variances are required. The remaining PWSFs, labeled "02," "03,""05,""06,""07," and "08," are on poles containing one small-cell antenna per pole. All poles will be the same height (29' including antenna). All but one pole will be designed to match the existing black, decorative light poles on the Ithaca College campus. Installation "03" will be near trees, on a short utility pole with antenna and equipment painted to blend in with the pole. None of the poles are near or within any scenic views. However, some may be located within 300' of a structure that contains a dwelling unit (as defined by Town Code), and may require an area variance from the Zoning Board of Appeals per Town Code Section 270-219.L(1)(b)[9] [e]. The proposal to install PWSFs on the Ithaca College campus will not result in significant adverse environmental impacts relative to traffic, historic/archaeological resources, slopes, wetlands/waterbodies, rare or endangered plant or animal species, or other natural resources. The facilities have been designed to have minimal aesthetic and visual impact (per Town Code 270-219. L). There will be minimal grading involved and all erosion control during construction will be in compliance with NYS and Town stormwater regulations. There will be no anticipated noise or lighting impacts, and no anticipated short-term, long-term, or cumulative adverse environmental impacts associated with the project. Regarding Part 1, number 13a, there is a NYS DEC-classified stream located more than 1,600 feet west of the property, in Buttermilk Falls State Park. The proposal will have no impact on the stream. Regarding Part 1, number 20, the remediation site listed is located across from the Ithaca College campus, at 950 Danby Road. It is the current home of the South Hill Business Campus, formerly Axhiom/National Cash Register. The property required environmental remediation before it was converted into the South Hill Business Campus in 2009. The proposal will have no impact on the remediation site. Town of Ithaca Planning Board Caitlin Cameron Chair Christine Balestra, Senior Planner Page 561 Page 1 of 5 PROPOSED RESOLUTION: Preliminary & Final Site Plan & Special Permit Verizon Wireless- Ithaca College Batched PWSF Project Ithaca College Campus & Circle Apartments Tax Parcel No.’s 41.-1-30.2 & 43.-1-2.2 Planning Board, October 6, 2026 WHEREAS: 1. This action is consideration of Preliminary & Final Site Plan and Special Permit Approval for the proposed Bell Atlantic Mobile Systems, LLC d/b/a Verizon Wireless Personal Wireless Service Facility (PWSF) Project, located on the Ithaca College Campus at 953 Danby Road, and the College Circle Apartments near the Community Center at 30 College Circle. The proposal is a batched PWSF application that includes eight (8) PWSF telecommunication facilities: one (1) macro PWSF array on the rooftop of Williams Hall, six (6) small cell PWSF antennas on decorative poles throughout campus, and one (1) small cell PWSF on the roof of Dillingham Hall. Ithaca College, Owner; Jared C. Lusk, Partner, Nixon Peabody, LLP, Applicant/Agent; 2. This is an Unlisted Action for which the Town of Ithaca Planning Board, on October 6, 2026, in an uncoordinated environmental review with respect to the proposal, made a negative determination of environmental significance, after having reviewed and accepted as adequate a completed Short Environmental Assessment Form Part 1, submitted and prepared by the applicant, and Parts 2 and 3 prepared by staff, 3. The Planning Board, at a public hearing on October 6, 2026, has reviewed and accepted as adequate application materials dated August 11, 2026, including Exhibits A-Z, along with eight (8) drawing sets prepared by Costitch Engineering, titled as follows: “Bell Atlantic Mobile Systems LLC d/b/a Verizon, Site Name: Ithaca College-Williams Hall Zoning Drawings, Project ID: 17032353, Mdg Location ID: 50000921791,” with sheets GA001-GA002, CA 100- 101, CA 110-111, CA 200-201, CA 500-505, RF001, EA 500-507, most recently revised 6/29/2026; “Verizon Site Name: Ithaca College-02, Project: 4G, Project ID: 17032360, Mdg Location ID: 50000921783, Latitude: 42.425342º (N), Longitude: -76.491169º (W), Pole No.: New Decorative Pole Set,” with sheets Z1-Z11, most recently revised 08/05/2026; “Verizon Site Name: Ithaca College-03, Project: 4G, Project ID: 17032361, Mdg Location ID: 50000921785, Latitude: 42.420922º (N), Longitude: -76.490636º (W), Pole No.: New Wood Pole Set,” with sheets Z1-Z8, most recently revised 07/29/2026; “Bell Atlantic Mobile Systems LLC d/b/a Verizon, Site Name: Ithaca College-04, Zoning Drawings, Project ID: 17032359, Mdg Location ID: 50000921786,” with sheets GA001-GA002, CA 100-101, CA 110, CA 200- 201, CA 500-505, RF001, EA 500-506, most recently revised 6/29/2026; “Verizon Site Name: Ithaca College-05, Project: 4G, Project ID: 17032354, Mdg Location ID: 50000921790, Latitude: 42.419922º (N), Longitude: -76.494811º (W), Pole No.: New Decorative Pole Set,” with sheets Z1-Z12, most recently revised 08/05/2026; “Verizon Site Name: Ithaca College-06, Project: 4G, Project ID: 17032358, Mdg Location ID: 50000921784, Latitude: 42.417714º (N), Longitude: -76.498022º (W), Pole No.: New Decorative Pole Set,” with sheets Z1-Z12, most recently revised 08/05/2026; “Verizon Site Name: Ithaca College-07, Project: 4G, Project ID: 17032357, Mdg Location ID: 50000921777, Latitude: 42.411722º (N), Longitude: -76.500003º (W), Pole No.: New Decorative Pole Set,” with sheets Z1-Z11, most recently revised 08/05/2026; “Verizon Site Name: Ithaca College-08, Project: 4G, Project ID: 17032356, Mdg Location ID: 50000921779, Latitude: 42.418989º (N), Longitude: -76.496969º (W), Pole No.: Page 562 Page 2 of 5 New Decorative Pole Set,” with sheets Z1-Z120, most recently revised 08/05/2026; and other plans and materials, and 4. Project plans, and related information, were duly delivered to the Tompkins County Planning and Sustainability Department per New York State General Municipal Law §§239-l et seq., and such Department responded in a September 25, 2026, letter from Katherine Borgella, Tompkins County Commissioner of Planning, pursuant to §§239-l, -m, and -n of the New York State General Municipal Law, determining that the proposed action will have no significant county- wide or inter-community impact; NOW, THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED: 1. That the Town of Ithaca Planning Board hereby grants Special Permit for the project, finding that the Special Permit standards of Article XXIV Section 270-200, Subsections A – H, of the Town of Ithaca Code, have been met, specifically that: A. The project will be suitable for the property on which it is proposed, considering the property’s size, location, and physical site characteristics. • The property is approximately 588+/- acres in size. It is a college campus with dormitory buildings, apartment buildings, utility poles, parking areas, bike paths, sidewalks, trails, and natural areas. The proposed project will involve almost no grading and will not impact the property size, location, or physical site characteristics. B. The proposed structure design and site layout are compatible with the surrounding area. • The site layout will not change. The proposed personal wireless facilities are designed to blend in with the overall Ithaca College campus utility pole and building designs and are compatible with all other utility poles/buildings on campus and at the Circle Apartments (owned and managed by Ithaca College). C. Operations in connection with the proposed use do not create any more noise, fumes, vibration, illumination, or other potential nuisances than the operation of any permitted use in the particular zone. • There will be significantly less noise impact associated with the proposed facilities than most permitted uses. The small-cell facilities on poles will not emit any noise, fumes, or vibration; and will not be illuminated. The macro facility on the rooftop of Williams Hall will contain equipment that is inside the building in a mechanical room, so any noise associated with the equipment will not be heard outside the room. The proposed small-cell facility on the roof of Dillingham hall will contain equipment near other mechanical rooftop equipment. It will emit far less noise than the other rooftop equipment. Other than safety lights, there will be no illumination of the proposed rooftop facilities. There will be no fumes, vibration, or other nuisances. D. Community infrastructure and services, such as police, fire and other protective services, roadways, schools, and water and sewer facilities are currently, or will be, of adequate capacity to accommodate the proposed use. • There are no needed changes to existing infrastructure and services. All infrastructure to accommodate the existing use is in place and is of adequate capacity. E. The proposed use, structure design, and site layout will comply with all the provisions of the Town Code and with the Town of Ithaca Comprehensive Plan. • The use and structure designs comply with all provisions of Town Code. Some pole sitings may require area variances by the Zoning Board of Appeals for being located less than 300ft Page 563 Page 3 of 5 from a dwelling unit (as defined by Town Code). The project is scheduled for the October 13, 2026, Zoning Board meeting. F. The site layout, with proposed vehicular, bicycle and pedestrian access, traffic circulation, and parking and loading facilities, is sufficient for the proposed use and is safely designed for emergency vehicles. • There is no parking, loading, bicycle, or pedestrian access required. The proposed facilities are located on building rooftops or throughout campus. None are within or impeding parking areas, sidewalks, or other pedestrian/bicycle access areas. G. The project includes sufficient landscaping and/or other forms of buffering to protect surrounding land uses. Existing vegetation is preserved to the extent possible. • There will be no loss to existing trees and vegetation. Buffering and additional landscaping is not recommended. H. To the extent deemed relevant by the Planning Board, the proposed use or structure complies with all the criteria applicable to site plan review set forth in Chapter 270, Zoning. 2. That the Planning Board further finds that all the requirements of §270-219.R(1) have been met, specifically: (a) The proposed personal wireless service facility complies with all relevant federal statutory and regulatory requirements, including all applicable Federal Communication Commission, Federal Aviation Commission, National Environmental Policy Act, and National Historic Preservation Act requirements. ➢ Application materials in Exhibits O, X, and Y show compliance with these laws. (b) The applicable standards in Chapter 270 (Zoning), Article XXIV (Special Permits and Special Approvals), § 270-200 (Considerations for approval) are met. ➢ See #1 above; and (c) All of the following additional standards are met: [1] Public utility status. Services provided by the proposed PWSFs are considered public utility services, and the provider of such services is considered a public utility, in the State of New York. ➢ Application materials in Exhibit I provide information supporting this finding. [2] Need. The applicant has proven a compelling need to address any significant gaps in the applicant's personal wireless services (the ability of wireless telephones to make and receive voice calls to and from landlines that are connected to the national telephone network) through the proposed facilities and not through any other solution, and the facility presents a minimal intrusion on the community. [a] To determine whether a gap is significant, the Planning Board shall consider, among other things, dropped call and failure rates, whether a gap is relatively large or small in geographic size, whether the number of the applicant's customers affected by the gap is relatively small or large, whether or not the location of the gap is situated on a lightly or heavily traveled road or in a sparsely or densely occupied area, and whether the applicant's customers are affected for only a limited period of time. A significant gap cannot be established simply because the applicant's personal wireless services operate on a frequency which is not the frequency most desired by the applicant. An applicant's claim of need for future capacity does not constitute evidence of a significant gap. Page 564 Page 4 of 5 [b] In making the finding of compelling need, the Planning Board shall consider the evidence of a significant gap, the applicant's consideration of other sites and other means of addressing the gaps, and the feasibility of addressing the gaps through the use of other sites or other means. ➢ The following information shows a compelling need to address significant gaps in the applicant’s personal wireless services through the proposed facilities and not through any other solution, and it shows the facility presents a minimal intrusion on the community: ➢ Application materials show that the gap in coverage, including capacity issues, can be addressed with a combination of macro and small cell facilities, with two proposed facilities collocated onto existing structures. The remaining facilities will be on small poles dispersed throughout campus. ➢ Exhibit M provides propagation plots and analysis showing coverage gaps in the area to be served by the proposed facilities, particularly within the mid-band range. Capacity gaps exist in all ranges. Coverage and capacity gaps are expected to be remedied with the proposed facilities. ➢ Exhibit T contains call testing data, drive test data, and dropped call data. Call testing data included indoor and outdoor call testing, with indoor testing performed via walk tests in 12 campus buildings. Drive test data included a driving route within and around the Ithaca College campus area and the College Circle Apartments. Dropped call data, with failed connections/attempts, is noted on sheet 29. Exhibit T illustrates significant gaps in coverage, dropped calls, and weak signals in all tested buildings and throughout test areas. [3] Compliance with Chapter 270 (Zoning) and other Town Code requirements. Complies with all requirements of this § 270-219, with all other requirements of this Chapter 270 (unless expressly superseded by this § 270-219), and all other applicable Ithaca Town Code requirements. ➢ See #1 E above. The project may require area variances from the Zoning Board of Appeals. The Planning Board does not have the authority to consider or grant area variances. The project will appear before the Zoning Board for consideration of variances on October 13, 2026. [4] Co-location on proposed towers. For non-SWFs, when construction of a tower is proposed, such a tower is designed to accommodate future shared use by at least two other PWSF providers. ➢ N/A. The proposal is for a collocation of a non-SWF onto an existing structure, collocation of a SWF onto an existing structure, and installation of small wireless facilities (SWFs) on small poles. Exhibit P outlines Verizon’s collocation policy. [5] Aesthetic impacts. The proposed PWSF will not inflict a significant adverse aesthetic impact upon properties that are located adjacent or in close proximity to the proposed site(s) or upon any other properties situated in a manner that such properties might reasonably be expected to sustain adverse aesthetic impacts. ➢ The proposed facilities are located outside of any views listed in the Tompkins County and Town of Ithaca Scenic Resources Inventories. They will be located entirely within the Ithaca College campus (College Circle Apartments are owned and managed by Ithaca College). There are no residences located in close proximity to the proposal. There is no anticipated adverse aesthetic impact expected. [6] Impacts upon real estate values. The proposed PWSFs will not inflict a significant adverse impact upon the property values of properties that are located adjacent or in close proximity to the proposed site(s). ➢ This finding is based on application materials in Exhibit V. [7] Impact upon the character of the surrounding community. The proposed PWSFs will not be incompatible with the use and character of properties located adjacent or in close proximity to the proposed site(s), or with any other properties situated in a manner that the PWSFs might reasonably be expected to be incompatible with such properties. Page 565 Page 5 of 5 ➢ This finding is based on the information and analysis in the Short Environmental Assessment Form Parts 2 & 3, and per Special Permit findings in resolved clause #1 above. [8] Mitigation. The applicant has mitigated the potential adverse impacts of the proposed PWSFs to the greatest extent reasonably feasible through siting, location, and design. ➢ The eight PWSFs have been specifically located away from residences and public viewpoints. The proposed antennas and associated equipment are as small as they can be to be as minimally intrusive as possible. The small cell antennas on poles were specifically designed to blend in with the existing decorative poles on campus; and, for the one wood pole, to blend in with the surrounding trees. 3. That the Town of Ithaca Planning Board hereby grants Preliminary & Final Site Plan Approval for the Bell Atlantic Mobile Systems, LLC d/b/a Verizon Wireless Personal Wireless Service Facility (PWSF) Project, located on the Ithaca College Campus at 953 Danby Road, and the College Circle Apartments near the Community Center at 30 College Circle, as described in Whereas #3 above, subject to the following conditions: a. Receipt of any necessary variances from the Town of Ithaca Zoning Board of Appeals, and b. Approval of a Basic Erosion and Sedimentation Control Plan (Basic SWPPP) by the Town of Ithaca Engineering Department, before issuance of any PWSF permits for the small cell pole applications labeled “02,” “03,” “05,” “06,” “07,” and “08.” Page 566 Page 567 Page 568 Page 569 Page 570 Page 571 Page 572 Page 573 Page 574 Page 575 Page 576 Page 577 Page 578 Page 579 Page 580 Page 581 Page 582 Page 583 Page 584 Page 585 Page 586 Page 587 Page 588 Page 589 Page 590 Page 591 Page 592 Page 593 Page 594 Page 595 Page 596 Pa g e 5 9 7 Pa g e 5 9 8 Pa g e 5 9 9 Pa g e 6 0 0 Pa g e 6 0 1 Pa g e 6 0 2 Page 603 Page 604 Page 605 Page 606 Page 607 Page 608 Page 609 Page 610 Page 611 Page 612 Page 613 Page 614 Page 615 Page 616 Page 617 Page 618 Page 619 Page 620 Page 621 Page 622 Page 623 Page 624 Page 625 Page 626 Page 627 Page 628 Page 629 Page 630 Page 631 Page 632 Page 633 Page 634 Page 635 Page 636 Page 637 Page 638 Page 639 Page 640 Page 641 Page 642 Page 643 Page 644 Page 645 Page 646 Page 647 Page 648 Page 649 Page 650 Page 651 Page 652 Page 653 Page 654 Page 655 Page 656 Page 657 Page 658 Page 659 Page 660 Page 661 Page 662 Page 663 Page 664 Page 665 Page 666 Page 667 Page 668 Page 669 Page 670 Page 671 Page 672 Page 673 Page 674 Page 675 Page 676 Page 677 Page 678 Page 679 Page 680 Page 681 Page 682 Page 683 Page 684 Page 685 Page 686 Page 687 Page 688 Page 689 Page 690 Page 691 Page 692 Page 693 Page 694 Page 695 Page 696 Page 697 Page 698 Page 699 Page 700 Page 701 Page 702 Page 703 Page 704 Page 705 Page 706 Pa g e 7 0 7 Pa g e 7 0 8 Pa g e 7 0 9 Pa g e 7 1 0 Pa g e 7 1 1 Pa g e 7 1 2 Page 713 Page 714 Page 715 Page 716 Page 717 Page 718 Page 719 Page 720 Page 721 Page 722 Page 723 Page 724 Page 725 Page 726 Page 727 Page 728 Page 729 Page 730 Page 731 Page 732 Page 733 Page 734 Page 735 Page 736 Page 737 Page 738 Page 739 Page 740 Page 741 Page 742 Page 743 Page 744 Page 745 Page 746 Page 747 Page 748 Page 749 Page 750 Page 751 Page 752 Page 753 Page 754 Page 755 Page 756 Page 757 Page 758 Page 759 Page 760 Page 761 Page 762 Page 763 Page 764 Page 765 Page 766 Page 767 Page 768 Page 769 Page 770 Page 771 Page 772 Page 773 Page 774 Page 775 Page 776 Page 777 Page 778 Page 779 Page 780 Page 781 Page 782 Page 783 Page 784 Page 785 Page 786 Page 787 Pa g e 7 8 8 Pa g e 7 8 9 Pa g e 7 9 0 Pa g e 7 9 1 Pa g e 7 9 2 Pa g e 7 9 3 Pa g e 7 9 4 Pa g e 7 9 5 Pa g e 7 9 6 Pa g e 7 9 7 Pa g e 7 9 8 Pa g e 7 9 9 Page 800 Page 801 Page 802 Page 803 Page 804 Page 805 Page 806 Page 807 Page 808 Page 809 Page 810 Page 811 Page 812 Page 813 Page 814 Page 815 Page 816 Page 817 Page 818 Page 819 Page 820 Page 821 Page 822 Page 823 Page 824 Page 825 Page 826 Page 827 Page 828 Page 829 Page 830 Page 831 Page 832 Page 833 Page 834 Page 835 Page 836 Page 837 Page 838 Page 839 Page 840 Page 841 Page 842 Page 843 Page 844 Page 845 Page 846 Page 847 Page 848 Page 849 Pa g e 8 5 0 Pa g e 8 5 1 Pa g e 8 5 2 Pa g e 8 5 3 Pa g e 8 5 4 Pa g e 8 5 5 Page 856 Page 857 Page 858 Page 859 Page 860 Page 861 Page 862 Page 863 Page 864 Page 865 Page 866 Page 867 Page 868 Page 869 Page 870 Page 871 Page 872 Page 873 Page 874 Page 875 Page 876 Page 877 Page 878 Page 879 Page 880 Page 881 Page 882 Page 883 Page 884 Page 885 Page 886 Page 887 Page 888 Page 889 Page 890 Page 891 Page 892 Page 893 Page 894 Page 895 Page 896 Page 897 Page 898 Page 899 Page 900 Page 901 Page 902 Page 903 Page 904 Page 905 Page 906 Page 907 Page 908 Page 909 Page 910 Page 911 Page 912 Page 913 Page 914 Page 915 Page 916 Page 917 Page 918 Page 919 Page 920 Page 921 Page 922 Page 923 Page 924 Page 925 Page 926 Page 927 Pa g e 9 2 8 Pa g e 9 2 9 Pa g e 9 3 0 Pa g e 9 3 1 Pa g e 9 3 2 Pa g e 9 3 3 Page 934 Page 935 Page 936 Page 937 Page 938 Page 939 Page 940 Page 941 Page 942 Page 943 Page 944 Page 945 Page 946 Page 947 Page 948 Page 949 Page 950 Page 951 Page 952 Page 953 Page 954 Page 955 Page 956 Page 957 Page 958 Page 959 Page 960 Page 961 Page 962 Page 963 Page 964 Page 965 Page 966 Page 967 Page 968 Page 969 Page 970 Page 971 Page 972 Page 973 Page 974 Page 975 Page 976 Page 977 Page 978 Page 979 Page 980 Page 981 Page 982 Page 983 Page 984 Page 985 Page 986 Page 987 Page 988 Page 989 Page 990 Page 991 Page 992 Page 993 Page 994 Page 995 Page 996 Page 997 Page 998 Page 999 Page 1000 Page 1001 Page 1002 Page 1003 Page 1004 Page 1005 Page 1006 Page 1007 Page 1008 Page 1009 Page 1010 Page 1011 Page 1012 Page 1013 Page 1014 Page 1015 Page 1016 Page 1017 Page 1018 Page 1019 Page 1020 Page 1021 Page 1022 Page 1023 Page 1024 Page 1025 Page 1026 Page 1027 Page 1028 Page 1029 Page 1030 Page 1031 Page 1032 Page 1033 Page 1034 Page 1035 Page 1036 Page 1037 Page 1038 Page 1039 Page 1040 Page 1041 Page 1042 Page 1043 Page 1044 Page 1045 Page 1046 Page 1047 Page 1048 Page 1049 Page 1050 Page 1051 Page 1052 Page 1053 Page 1054 Page 1055 COMMISSIONER Katherine Borgella DEPUTY COMMISSIONER M. Megan McDonald 121 E. Court St, Ithaca, N.Y. 14850 | Phone: (607) 274-5560 | tompkinscountyny.gov/planning Creating and implementing plans that position Tompkins County communities to thrive. September 25, 2026 Christine Balestra, Senior Planner Town of Ithaca 215 North Tioga St. Ithaca, NY 14850 Re: Review Pursuant to §239 -l, -m and -n of New York State General Municipal Law Proposed Action: Special Use Permit and Site Plan for proposed Bell Atlantic Mobile Systems LLC D/B/A Verizon Wireless PWSF Project located at 953 Danby Road and near 30 College Circle, Tax Parcel # 41.-1-30.2 & 43.-1-2.2, Ithaca College, Owner; Jared Lusk, Partner, Nixon Peabody, Applicant. Dear Ms. Balestra: This letter acknowledges your referral of the proposed action identified above for review by the Tompkins County Department of Planning and Sustainability pursuant to §239 -l, -m and -n of the New York State General Municipal Law. We have determined the proposed action will have no significant county-wide or inter-community impact. We look forward to receiving notification on the final action taken by your municipality within 30 days of decision, as required by State law. Sincerely, Katherine Borgella, AICP Commissioner of Planning and Sustainability Page 1056 Page 1 of 5 PROPOSED RESOLUTION: Preliminary & Final Site Plan & Special Permit Verizon Wireless- Ithaca College Batched PWSF Project Ithaca College Campus & Circle Apartments Tax Parcel No.’s 41.-1-30.2 & 43.-1-2.2 Planning Board, October 6, 2026 WHEREAS: 1. This action is consideration of Preliminary & Final Site Plan and Special Permit Approval for the proposed Bell Atlantic Mobile Systems, LLC d/b/a Verizon Wireless Personal Wireless Service Facility (PWSF) Project, located on the Ithaca College Campus at 953 Danby Road, and the College Circle Apartments near the Community Center at 30 College Circle. The proposal is a batched PWSF application that includes eight (8) PWSF telecommunication facilities: one (1) macro PWSF array on the rooftop of Williams Hall, six (6) small cell PWSF antennas on decorative poles throughout campus, and one (1) small cell PWSF on the roof of Dillingham Hall. Ithaca College, Owner; Jared C. Lusk, Partner, Nixon Peabody, LLP, Applicant/Agent; 2. This is an Unlisted Action for which the Town of Ithaca Planning Board, on October 6, 2026, in an uncoordinated environmental review with respect to the proposal, made a negative determination of environmental significance, after having reviewed and accepted as adequate a completed Short Environmental Assessment Form Part 1, submitted and prepared by the applicant, and Parts 2 and 3 prepared by staff, 3. The Planning Board, at a public hearing on October 6, 2026, has reviewed and accepted as adequate application materials dated August 11, 2026, including Exhibits A-Z, along with eight (8) drawing sets prepared by Costitch Engineering, titled as follows: “Bell Atlantic Mobile Systems LLC d/b/a Verizon, Site Name: Ithaca College-Williams Hall Zoning Drawings, Project ID: 17032353, Mdg Location ID: 50000921791,” with sheets GA001-GA002, CA 100- 101, CA 110-111, CA 200-201, CA 500-505, RF001, EA 500-507, most recently revised 6/29/2026; “Verizon Site Name: Ithaca College-02, Project: 4G, Project ID: 17032360, Mdg Location ID: 50000921783, Latitude: 42.425342º (N), Longitude: -76.491169º (W), Pole No.: New Decorative Pole Set,” with sheets Z1-Z11, most recently revised 08/05/2026; “Verizon Site Name: Ithaca College-03, Project: 4G, Project ID: 17032361, Mdg Location ID: 50000921785, Latitude: 42.420922º (N), Longitude: -76.490636º (W), Pole No.: New Wood Pole Set,” with sheets Z1-Z8, most recently revised 07/29/2026; “Bell Atlantic Mobile Systems LLC d/b/a Verizon, Site Name: Ithaca College-04, Zoning Drawings, Project ID: 17032359, Mdg Location ID: 50000921786,” with sheets GA001-GA002, CA 100-101, CA 110, CA 200- 201, CA 500-505, RF001, EA 500-506, most recently revised 6/29/2026; “Verizon Site Name: Ithaca College-05, Project: 4G, Project ID: 17032354, Mdg Location ID: 50000921790, Latitude: 42.419922º (N), Longitude: -76.494811º (W), Pole No.: New Decorative Pole Set,” with sheets Z1-Z12, most recently revised 08/05/2026; “Verizon Site Name: Ithaca College-06, Project: 4G, Project ID: 17032358, Mdg Location ID: 50000921784, Latitude: 42.417714º (N), Longitude: -76.498022º (W), Pole No.: New Decorative Pole Set,” with sheets Z1-Z12, most recently revised 08/05/2026; “Verizon Site Name: Ithaca College-07, Project: 4G, Project ID: 17032357, Mdg Location ID: 50000921777, Latitude: 42.411722º (N), Longitude: -76.500003º (W), Pole No.: New Decorative Pole Set,” with sheets Z1-Z11, most recently revised 08/05/2026; “Verizon Site Name: Ithaca College-08, Project: 4G, Project ID: 17032356, Mdg Location ID: 50000921779, Latitude: 42.418989º (N), Longitude: -76.496969º (W), Pole No.: Page 1057 Page 2 of 5 New Decorative Pole Set,” with sheets Z1-Z120, most recently revised 08/05/2026; and other plans and materials, and 4. Project plans, and related information, were duly delivered to the Tompkins County Planning and Sustainability Department per New York State General Municipal Law §§239-l et seq., and such Department responded in a September 25, 2026, letter from Katherine Borgella, Tompkins County Commissioner of Planning, pursuant to §§239-l, -m, and -n of the New York State General Municipal Law, determining that the proposed action will have no significant county- wide or inter-community impact; NOW, THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED: 1. That the Town of Ithaca Planning Board hereby grants Special Permit for the project, finding that the Special Permit standards of Article XXIV Section 270-200, Subsections A – H, of the Town of Ithaca Code, have been met, specifically that: A. The project will be suitable for the property on which it is proposed, considering the property’s size, location, and physical site characteristics. • The property is approximately 588+/- acres in size. It is a college campus with dormitory buildings, apartment buildings, utility poles, parking areas, bike paths, sidewalks, trails, and natural areas. The proposed project will involve almost no grading and will not impact the property size, location, or physical site characteristics. B. The proposed structure design and site layout are compatible with the surrounding area. • The site layout will not change. The proposed personal wireless facilities are designed to blend in with the overall Ithaca College campus utility pole and building designs and are compatible with all other utility poles/buildings on campus and at the Circle Apartments (owned and managed by Ithaca College). C. Operations in connection with the proposed use do not create any more noise, fumes, vibration, illumination, or other potential nuisances than the operation of any permitted use in the particular zone. • There will be significantly less noise impact associated with the proposed facilities than most permitted uses. The small-cell facilities on poles will not emit any noise, fumes, or vibration; and will not be illuminated. The macro facility on the rooftop of Williams Hall will contain equipment that is inside the building in a mechanical room, so any noise associated with the equipment will not be heard outside the room. The proposed small-cell facility on the roof of Dillingham hall will contain equipment near other mechanical rooftop equipment. It will emit far less noise than the other rooftop equipment. Other than safety lights, there will be no illumination of the proposed rooftop facilities. There will be no fumes, vibration, or other nuisances. D. Community infrastructure and services, such as police, fire and other protective services, roadways, schools, and water and sewer facilities are currently, or will be, of adequate capacity to accommodate the proposed use. • There are no needed changes to existing infrastructure and services. All infrastructure to accommodate the existing use is in place and is of adequate capacity. E. The proposed use, structure design, and site layout will comply with all the provisions of the Town Code and with the Town of Ithaca Comprehensive Plan. • The use and structure designs comply with all provisions of Town Code. Some pole sitings may require area variances by the Zoning Board of Appeals for being located less than 300ft Page 1058 Page 3 of 5 from a dwelling unit (as defined by Town Code). The project is scheduled for the October 13, 2026, Zoning Board meeting. F. The site layout, with proposed vehicular, bicycle and pedestrian access, traffic circulation, and parking and loading facilities, is sufficient for the proposed use and is safely designed for emergency vehicles. • There is no parking, loading, bicycle, or pedestrian access required. The proposed facilities are located on building rooftops or throughout campus. None are within or impeding parking areas, sidewalks, or other pedestrian/bicycle access areas. G. The project includes sufficient landscaping and/or other forms of buffering to protect surrounding land uses. Existing vegetation is preserved to the extent possible. • There will be no loss to existing trees and vegetation. Buffering and additional landscaping is not recommended. H. To the extent deemed relevant by the Planning Board, the proposed use or structure complies with all the criteria applicable to site plan review set forth in Chapter 270, Zoning. 2. That the Planning Board further finds that all the requirements of §270-219.R(1) have been met, specifically: (a) The proposed personal wireless service facility complies with all relevant federal statutory and regulatory requirements, including all applicable Federal Communication Commission, Federal Aviation Commission, National Environmental Policy Act, and National Historic Preservation Act requirements. ➢ Application materials in Exhibits O, X, and Y show compliance with these laws. (b) The applicable standards in Chapter 270 (Zoning), Article XXIV (Special Permits and Special Approvals), § 270-200 (Considerations for approval) are met. ➢ See #1 above; and (c) All of the following additional standards are met: [1] Public utility status. Services provided by the proposed PWSFs are considered public utility services, and the provider of such services is considered a public utility, in the State of New York. ➢ Application materials in Exhibit I provide information supporting this finding. [2] Need. The applicant has proven a compelling need to address any significant gaps in the applicant's personal wireless services (the ability of wireless telephones to make and receive voice calls to and from landlines that are connected to the national telephone network) through the proposed facilities and not through any other solution, and the facility presents a minimal intrusion on the community. [a] To determine whether a gap is significant, the Planning Board shall consider, among other things, dropped call and failure rates, whether a gap is relatively large or small in geographic size, whether the number of the applicant's customers affected by the gap is relatively small or large, whether or not the location of the gap is situated on a lightly or heavily traveled road or in a sparsely or densely occupied area, and whether the applicant's customers are affected for only a limited period of time. A significant gap cannot be established simply because the applicant's personal wireless services operate on a frequency which is not the frequency most desired by the applicant. An applicant's claim of need for future capacity does not constitute evidence of a significant gap. Page 1059 Page 4 of 5 [b] In making the finding of compelling need, the Planning Board shall consider the evidence of a significant gap, the applicant's consideration of other sites and other means of addressing the gaps, and the feasibility of addressing the gaps through the use of other sites or other means. ➢ The following information shows a compelling need to address significant gaps in the applicant’s personal wireless services through the proposed facilities and not th rough any other solution, and it shows the facility presents a minimal intrusion on the community: ➢ Application materials show that the gap in coverage, including capacity issues, can be addressed with a combination of macro and small cell facilities, with two proposed facilities collocated onto existing structures. The remaining facilities will be on small poles dispersed throughout campus. ➢ Exhibit M provides propagation plots and analysis showing coverage gaps in the area to be served by the proposed facilities, particularly within the mid-band range. Capacity gaps exist in all ranges. Coverage and capacity gaps are expected to be remedied with the proposed facilities. ➢ Exhibit T contains call testing data, drive test data, and dropped call data. Call testing data included indoor and outdoor call testing, with indoor testing performed via walk tests in 12 campus buildings. Drive test data included a driving route within and around the Ithaca College campus area and the College Circle Apartments. Dropped call data, with failed connections/attempts, is noted on sheet 29. Exhibit T illustrates significant gaps in coverage, dropped calls, and weak signals in all tested buildings and throughout test areas. [3] Compliance with Chapter 270 (Zoning) and other Town Code requirements. Complies with all requirements of this § 270-219, with all other requirements of this Chapter 270 (unless expressly superseded by this § 270-219), and all other applicable Ithaca Town Code requirements. ➢ See #1 E above. The project may require area variances from the Zoning Board of Appeals. The Planning Board does not have the authority to consider or grant area variances. The project will appear before the Zoning Board for consideration of variances on October 13, 2026. [4] Co-location on proposed towers. For non-SWFs, when construction of a tower is proposed, such a tower is designed to accommodate future shared use by at least two other PWSF providers. ➢ N/A. The proposal is for a collocation of a non-SWF onto an existing structure, collocation of a SWF onto an existing structure, and installation of small wireless facilities (SWFs) on small poles. Exhibit P outlines Verizon’s collocation policy. [5] Aesthetic impacts. The proposed PWSF will not inflict a significant adverse aesthetic impact upon properties that are located adjacent or in close proximity to the proposed site(s) or upon any other properties situated in a manner that such properties might reasonably be expected to sustain adverse aesthetic impacts. ➢ The proposed facilities are located outside of any views listed in the Tompkins County and Town of Ithaca Scenic Resources Inventories. They will be located entirely within the Ithaca College campus (College Circle Apartments are owned and managed by Ithaca College). There are no residences located in close proximity to the proposal. There is no anticipated adverse aesthetic impact expected. [6] Impacts upon real estate values. The proposed PWSFs will not inflict a significant adverse impact upon the property values of properties that are located adjacent or in close proximity to the proposed site(s). ➢ This finding is based on application materials in Exhibit V. [7] Impact upon the character of the surrounding community. The proposed PWSFs will not be incompatible with the use and character of properties located adjacent or in close proximity to the proposed site(s), or with any other properties situated in a manner that the PWSFs might reasonably be expected to be incompatible with such properties. Page 1060 Page 5 of 5 ➢ This finding is based on the information and analysis in the Short Environmental Assessment Form Parts 2 & 3, and per Special Permit findings in resolved clause #1 above. [8] Mitigation. The applicant has mitigated the potential adverse impacts of the proposed PWSFs to the greatest extent reasonably feasible through siting, location, and design. ➢ The eight PWSFs have been specifically located away from residences and public viewpoints. The proposed antennas and associated equipment are as small as they can be to be as minimally int rusive as possible. The small cell antennas on poles were specifically designed to blend in with the existing decorative poles on campus; and, for the one wood pole, to blend in with the surrounding trees. 3. That the Town of Ithaca Planning Board hereby grants Preliminary & Final Site Plan Approval for the Bell Atlantic Mobile Systems, LLC d/b/a Verizon Wireless Personal Wireless Service Facility (PWSF) Project, located on the Ithaca College Campus at 953 Danby Road, and the College Circle Apartments near the Community Center at 30 College Circle, as described in Whereas #3 above, subject to the following conditions: a. Receipt of any necessary variances from the Town of Ithaca Zoning Board of Appeals, and b. Approval of a Basic Erosion and Sedimentation Control Plan (Basic SWPPP) by the Town of Ithaca Engineering Department, before issuance of any PWSF permits for the small cell pole applications labeled “02,” “03,” “05,” “06,” “07,” and “08.” Page 1061 PB 2026-09-01 (Filed 9/25) Pg. 1 TOWN OF ITHACA PLANNING BOARD September 1, 2026 DRAFT MINUTES The courtesy video recording of this meeting is available on YouTube @TownofIthacaVideo (Written comments submitted at the meeting or after posting of the official mailout packet and 24 hours after the meeting can be found in the updated packet online and will be filed permanently with the project folder along with any other comments received after the post meeting deadline.) Present: Caitlin Cameron, Chair; Liz Bageant, Sara Reynolds, Kelda McGurk, Vincent Ferrara and Jenni Minner Absent: Bill Arms Planning - CJ Randall, Director, Christine Balestra and Nick Quilty-Koval; Engineering - Justin McNeal, Director and Emily Rodgers; Nate VanWhy, Attorney for the Town; Dana Magnuson, Senior Code Officer; Paulette Rosa, Town Clerk Ms. Cameron called the meeting to order. 1. Persons to be heard • Stanley Hiller spoke, saying that he is the owner of the Sunny Gables property, and expressed concerns regarding the proposed Local 81 Plumbers and Steam Fitters Union project. He characterized the project as a 24,000-square-foot industrial facility that includes a 7,000-square-foot welding shop and an attached 2,300-square-foot union hall and asserted that 90% of the project is implicitly or explicitly prohibited by the Inlet Valley Overlay Zone and questioned the applicant's desire for commercial rezoning and stated that it should not be allowed. • Lainey Papageorge spoke saying that she is one of many residents of the Inlet Valley Homeowner Association, and she was concerned about the Local 81 project because the Inlet Valley is a wetland and should be protected. She argued that the introduction of concrete, gravel, and large infrastructure would negatively impact the local ecosystem and pollute the Finger Lakes water basin. She added that she had submitted written comments.. Ms. Cameron noted for the record that the project is not under review for any action tonight other than the Planning Board declaring its intent to act as Lead Agency in the environmental review. There will be other opportunities for public comment and the Board’s review. 2. Consideration of SEQR and Preliminary Site Plan Approval for the proposed Bomber Heights Solar large-scale community solar photovoltaic system project, located on Troy Road, between Coddington Road and King Road East, in the Low-Density Residential Zone and Large-Scale Photovoltaic Solar Energy System Overlay District. The project involves installing a 5MWac single-axis sun tracking solar array system on approximately 31+/- acres Page 1062 PB 2026-09-01 (Filed 9/25) Pg. 2 of land, along with two inverter/transformer equipment pads, battery energy storage, new utility (NYSEG) poles, eight-foot-tall fencing, stormwater management facilities, access drive, and other site elements. This is a Type I Action under the State Enviro nmental Quality Review Act and is subject to environmental review. The Planning Board declared their intent to be Lead Agency in the environmental review of the project on March 3, 2026. Troy Heights, LLC, Owner; Nexamp Solar, Applicant; Ryan McCune, Agent. Overview Ryan McHune, Vice President of Business Development at Nexamp, provided a technical summary of revisions made since March 2024. Key updates included: • Civil Engineering: Modifications to stormwater features to address tributaries and drainage points, complying with Barton & Loguidice's review. • Visual Renderings: Updated depictions of the facility from public rights-of-way. • Geotechnical Testing: On-site infiltration testing and full geotechnical studies confirming the feasibility of the racking solutions. Questions • Fencing – to satisfy National Electric Code, the fence will be 7’ feet high around the perimeter of the property in a “fixed knot farm fence” style and will be wildlife friendly with a 2-“ gap at the bottom, the same as was used for the Mecklenburg Rd appr oved project. The mechanical equipment is not enclosed further; which meets zoning and fire safety access preferences. • Tree clearing – The applicant noted that they have elected to request comprehensive clearing or “worst case” scenario and the associated Zoning Board variance. Selective tree preservation is not feasible given several shading issues and structural fall hazards. o The southeast and southwest corners of the site’s trees will be preserved. o No pesticides will be used other than to eradicate targeted invasive species currently onsite. SEQR DETERMINATION - Parts 1 & 2 Review and Revisions • Part 1 item G Structures – The applicant clarified that the project features 8,556 solar panels (single-panel racking system, unlike Carrowmoor ’s double-panel setup) with a maximum height of 12 feet at full tilt, width of 6’3”, and maximum row length of 350 feet with no heating or cooling required. • Part 1 Item N Outdoor lighting – changed to “no” because the camera pole was mistaken for a light pole – any lighting would have to meet Town Code • Part 1 Item E Water Impacts – Applicant clarified that permanent impervious surface impacts are entirely road-related due to fire code requirements for a 20’ foot access road. • Part 2 Item 7 Impact on Plans and Animals – Reviewed as moderate without mitigation. Lengthy discussion followed during review of Part 3. SEQR Part 3 Review and Revisions Page 1063 PB 2026-09-01 (Filed 9/25) Pg. 3 • Threatened Species (Glaucous and Reflexed Sedges): Lengthy discussion on the Labella Habitat Assessment Report, which was conducted in January, a season when finding sedges is difficult. However, the New York Flora Atlas indicates Glaucous and Reflexed Sedges are primarily located in the Hudson Valley, though documented in Tompkins County. • Regarding the Glaucous and Reflexed Sedge, the Board concluded that : "Given that the sedge species has not been confirmed on the site and no other information has been presented, and sedge has been identified on other parcels in the vicinity and is actively protected, the board finds potential presence is not so great that it rises above a small impact." This finding was further supported by the fact that the species is actively managed on adjacent lands, specifically the Ithaca College Natural Lands and Negundo Woods, where it is actively protected, mitigating the regional significance of potential habitat loss on the subject site. • Northern Long-Eared Bat (NLEB) and Tri-colored Bat: Lengthy discussion on the Labella Habitat Assessment Report, which contained pictures and a description of NLEB/Tri-Colored bat roosting and habitat sites, which is the first time Planning staff encountered a report that indicated the presence of potential habitat. However, Planning Board chose to follow the US Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS) determination of "Not Likely To Adversely Affect." The Board mandated a strict tree-clearing window between November 1 and March 31 to protect potential roosting habitats for both the NLEB and the Tri-colored bat. • Wetlands: The Board noted the DEC’s determination of the wetlands as non- jurisdictional (letter in application materials). The applicant will still need to submit materials to Army Corps of Engineers to see if a Nationwide Permit will be required. PB Resolution 2026-007: SEQR Preliminary Site Plan Approval Bomber Heights Large-Scale Solar Energy System Tax Parcel No. 49.-1-26.2 Troy Road, between Coddington and King Road E Whereas: 1. This action involves consideration of Preliminary Site Plan Approval for the proposed Bomber Heights Solar large-scale community solar photovoltaic system project, located on Troy Road, between Coddington Road and King Road East, in the Low Density Residential Zone and Large-Scale Photovoltaic Solar Energy System Overlay District. The project involves installing a 5MWac single-axis sun tracking solar array system on approximately 31+/- acres of land, along with two inverter/transformer equipment pads, battery energy storage, new utility (NYSEG) poles, eight-foot-tall fencing, stormwater management Page 1064 PB 2026-09-01 (Filed 9/25) Pg. 4 facilities, access drive, and other site elements. Troy Heights, LLC, Owner; Nexamp Solar, Applicant; Ryan McCune, Agent; 2. This is a Type I Action pursuant to State Environmental Quality Review Act, 6 NYCRR Part 617 (617.4(b)(6)(i)), because the project involves the physical alteration of more than 10 acres; 3. At its meeting on March 3, 2026, the Planning Board proposed to establish itself as Lead Agency to coordinate the environmental review of the above-referenced proposal, and on March 4, 2026, notified potential Involved and Interested Agencies of its intent to serve as Lead Agency; 4. The Planning Board, on September 1, 2026, has reviewed and accepted as adequate a Full Environmental Assessment Form Part 1, submitted by the applicant, Parts 2 and 3, prepared by Town Planning staff; an application narrative titled “Project Overview and Narrative, Bomber Heights Solar, Troy Road, Town of Ithaca, NY,” a set of drawings titled “Bomber Heights Solar, Troy Road, Ithaca, NY,14850” prepared by LaBella, dated December 2025, and most recently updated 07/10/2026, including sheets C001, C100-C101, C200-C203, C401-C407, C501-504, L101-103; Line of Sight Profile Plans, prepared by LaBella, dated December 2025; Photo Simulations, prepared by Saratoga Associates, dated 3/10/2026 and 4/08/2026; a Wetlands Delineation Report, Decommissioning Plan, Glint and Glare Study, Operations and Maintenance Plan, Battery Energy Storage System Emergency Response Plan, and other application materials; and 5. The Town Planning staff has recommended a negative determination of environmental significance with respect to the proposal; now, therefore be it Resolved: That the Town of Ithaca Planning Board, having received no objections from other Involved Agencies, establishes itself as Lead Agency to coordinate the environmental review of the above- described proposal; and be it Further Resolved: That the Town of Ithaca Planning Board hereby makes a negative determination of environmental significance in accordance with Article 8 of the Environmental Conservation Law and 6 NYCRR Part 617 New York State Environmental Quality Review for the above ref erenced proposal, based on the information in the EAF Part 1 and for the reasons set forth in the EAF Parts 2 and 3, and, therefore, a Draft Environmental Impact Statement will not be required. Moved: Vinnie Ferrara Seconded: Liz Bagenat Vote: ayes – Minner, Bageant, Cameron, Ferrara, Reynolds, and McGurk PUBLIC HEARING Page 1065 PB 2026-09-01 (Filed 9/25) Pg. 5 Ms. Cameron opened the public hearing. • Nancy Corer, Troy Rd: Noted discrepancies between the narrative, which states roadside vegetation along Troy Road would remain, and the renderings which showed extensive clearing. She requested accurate representation of their intentions. • Janice F, Coddington Rd: Raised concerns regarding downslope drainage toward Coddington Road and winter viewshed glare from the panels and whether the depictions accurately show what the neighbors would see, particularly during the winter. • Jared Mes, President, Local IBEW: Advocated for the use of local union labor. • Mike Parker, adjacent property owner to the north: Asked about property line setbacks for the fence and clear cutting and any potential noise from conversion stations near his northern property line. He also asked about security cameras and whether they would be able to see into his property or home. Ms. Cameron asked Mr. McCune to comment on the comments heard. • Regarding Mr. Parker comments, clearing of trees will happen up to the shared northern property line in that area; approximately 561’ feet for the safety reasons stated previously. • Setbacks – the fence will be approximately 63’ feet (50’ required) and equipment approximately 88’ (75’ required) feet from the shared property line. • Noise - Inverters and battery storage are centered on the site with the closest property line approximately 256’ feet away and noise generated is less than 43dB at 100’ feet, similar to a dishwasher. • Video surveillance is on the central camera pole and 360 degrees with an infrared safety cameras to monitor the battery and for site security. This is what they would use to see the property remotely and determine whether they need to plow and standard security reasons. • Regarding Janice F’s comments, drainage is addressed by the Stormwater Pollution prevention Plan which includes bio retention ponds to ensure no increase in runoff. • Glare - The panels have tracking technology that constantly adjusts panel angles to mitigate glare. Ms. Cameron closed the public hearing. Determination - Preliminary Site Plan Approval Discussion and revisions to the draft resolution. Tree Survey – Mr. Moseley had requested a tree survey per Town Code, associated with the variance request. Mr. McCune argued that a tree survey is not necessary because they are admitting they are going over the amount permitted, identifying all trees equal or great er than 6” in diameter, to assess compliance with clear-cutting limits under Town Code and are seeking a variance. Planning staff argued that clear-cutting more than 4 times the permitted area, in an area that reports show may contain habitat for an endangered species (NLEB) is very poor Page 1066 PB 2026-09-01 (Filed 9/25) Pg. 6 environmental conservation practice. Staff strongly recommended the Board consider the requirements listed in the draft resolution. The Board decided that the ZBA should determine what information is needed for the variance and they removed the detailed tree survey requirement on the draft resolution. Vegetation – The Board was in favor of requiring a Vegetation Management Plan (VMP), using native perennial seed mixes to support pollinators and game/songbirds. Visual Screening - In response to public comments about removing existing screening along Troy Road, and Board concerns regarding the "Christmas tree look" of the proposed evergreen screen, the Board added a new condition for submission of a more diverse screen planting and revised photo simulations that include native shrubs along Troy Road, as well as the more diverse trees. Clearing Restrictions – Concerns about validating the presence of and protection of native sedge grass(es) and the protection of native bats were discussed at length. The majority of the Board agreed that the sedge grass was prevalent in numerous other areas of the town, many in protected preserves or agricultural easements, and when taken in scale, the possible disturbance during and for this project did not rise to the level that requires a condition or further actions by the applicant. The tree clearing window was restricted to between November 1st and March 31st to limit any impacts on the nesting of the bats and removed the requirement of an acoustic survey for the bats. The condition regarding lighting was removed as no lighting is proposed. PB Resolution 2026-008: Preliminary Site Plan Approval Bomber Heights Large-Scale Solar Energy System Tax Parcel No. 49.-1-26.2 Troy Road, between Coddington and King Road E Whereas: 1. This action involves consideration of Preliminary Site Plan Approval for the proposed Bomber Heights Solar large-scale community solar photovoltaic system project, located on Troy Road, between Coddington Road and King Road East, in the Low Density Residential Zone and Large-Scale Photovoltaic Solar Energy System Overlay District. The project involves installing a 5MWac single-axis sun tracking solar array system on approximately 31+/- acres of land, along with two inverter/transformer equipment pads, battery energy storage, new utility (NYSEG) poles, eight-foot-tall fencing, stormwater management facilities, access drive, and other site elements. Troy Heights, LLC, Owner; Nexamp Solar, Applicant; Ryan McCune, Agent; Page 1067 PB 2026-09-01 (Filed 9/25) Pg. 7 2. This is a Type I Action for which the Town of Ithaca Planning Board, acting as Lead Agency the environmental review with respect to this project on September 1, 2026, made a negative determination of environmental significance, after having reviewed and accepted as adequate a Full Environmental Assessment Form Part 1, submitted by the applicant, Parts 2 and 3, prepared by Town Planning staff, and other application materials; and 3. The Planning Board, at a public hearing held on September 1, 2026, has reviewed and accepted as adequate an application narrative titled “Project Overview and Narrative, Bomber Heights Solar, Troy Road, Town of Ithaca, NY,” a set of drawings titled “Bomber Heights Solar, Troy Road, Ithaca, NY,14850” prepared by LaBella, dated December 2025, and most recently updated 07/10/2026, including sheets C001, C100-C101, C200-C203, C401-C407, C501-504, L101-103; Line of Sight Profile Plans, prepared by LaBella, dated December 2025; Photo Simulations, prepared by Saratoga Associates, dated 3/10/2026 and 4/08/2026; a Wetlands Delineation Report, Decommissioning Plan, Glint and Glare Study, Operations and Maintenance Plan, Battery Energy Storage System Emergency Response Plan, and other application materials; now, therefore be it Resolved: That the Town of Ithaca Planning Board hereby grants Preliminary Site Plan Approval for the proposed Bomber Heights Solar project, located on Troy Road, between Coddington Road and King Road East, as described in the materials listed in Whereas #3 above, subject to the following conditions: Before final site plan approval: 1. Submission of a Vegetation management plan in accordance with Town Code § 270- 219.1G(2)(c)[5][b], 2. Receipt of any necessary variances from the Zoning Board of Appeals, 3. Submission to, and approval by, the Town of Ithaca Engineering Department, of all items listed in the memo dated August 19, 2026, from Charles A. White, P.E., Barton & Loguidice, D.P.C, to Justin McNeal, Director of Engineering, 4. Submission of a more diverse screening planting module and revised photo simulations that include a mix of native shrubs and existing shrubs along Troy Road, as well as the proposed trees, Before any tree clearing: 5. To mitigate potential impacts on any roosting habitats for the NLEB and tri-colored bats, the applicant shall minimize clearing and leave as many potential roosts as possible, including snag and cavity trees. All tree removal must take place between Nov.1 and March 31, Before issuance of a building permit: 6. Submission to the Planning Department of any required stream or wetland permit Page 1068 PB 2026-09-01 (Filed 9/25) Pg. 8 documentation issued by the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation and/or the Army Corps of Engineers, 7. Approval of the Decommissioning Plan and Bond by the Attorney for the Town and the Town Engineer, 8. All pollinator seed mixes applied after construction shall contain plant species preferred by the monarch butterfly; and proposed herbicide application shall not be harmful to pollinators, 9. Submission to the Planning Department of a copy of Tompkins County Highway Construction Permit(s), and 10. Scheduling of a coordination meeting with the Applicant’s Environmental Monitor, and the Town Engineering, Planning, and Codes Departments. Moved: Sara Reynolds Seconded: Liz Bageant Vote: Ayes – Reynolds, Bageant, Cameron, McGurk, and Ferrara Nays – Minner 3. Sketch Plan for the proposed Plumbers and Steamfitters (Local 81 Union) new Joint Apprentice Training Center building project, located on Elmira Road, between Enfield Falls Road and Park Lane, in the Low Density Residential Zone and the Inlet Valley Overlay District (IV-T zone). The project involves constructing a +/- 23,700 square foot building on +/- 9 acres of land, along with parking facilities, outdoor training areas, a public use walking trail, and other site plan elements. This is a Type I Action under the State Environmental Quality Review Act and is subject to environmental review. There are no decisions or approvals at this meeting, other than the Planning Board declaring their intent to be Lead Agency in the environmental review of the project. Plumbers and Steamfitters Local 81, Owner; Tommy Hayward, Applicant; Ed Keplinger, Agent. Overview Ed Keplinger, Landscape Architect at Keplinger Freeman Associates;, Brian Manthey, Architect; and Chas Porter, Local 81 Training Coordinator, presented the Elmira Road project. The facility is designed to house union offices, classrooms, and a specialized training facilities: • Local 81 currently conducts operations in an outdated and undersized building located in the City of Ithaca on the corner of Fulton St. • This project proposes a new +/-23,700 square foot building in the Town located on Elmira Road. • Included in the sketch plan of the building are office space, a union meeting room, six classrooms/labs, a 7,000 sq. ft. welding training shop, a loading dock, a steel-framed solar array, and a "sandbox" (an outdoor module utilized for underground plumbing, drainage, and utility training). • The project includes 82 parking spaces, 74 for union operations and eight (8) for fishing access. Chas Porter (Training Coordinator) clarified that operations will transition from a night school model to a day school program, averaging 25 apprentices per day. The 82 Page 1069 PB 2026-09-01 (Filed 9/25) Pg. 9 spaces are required to accommodate a monthly union meeting held on the fourth Wednesday of each month, where up to 100 people attend. • Proposes a public walking trail and parking spaces to provide access to a fishing spot and connect with the planned southern expansion of the Black Diamond Trail. • Proposes evergreens (spruce/pine mix) and a 6-foot fence along the Sunny Gables property line for screening. Discussion • Zoning & Use: The project is proposed as a local union classified under the Inlet Valley Overlay District (IVOD) as a private club/lounge. • A Special Permit is required, and a use interpretation is scheduled for the ZBA on September 22, 2026. • Setbacks & Buffering: The Board noted that some paved parking and service areas encroached closely on setbacks and property lines. Staff noted that the IVOD requires a minimum 10-foot wide landscaping buffer for paved areas near side or rear lot lines. The Board noted that screening along the roadway is important. • Aesthetics & Materials: The Board appreciated the massing variation but expressed concerns that the cool gray, industrial color palette felt overly industrial and suburban. The board suggested integrating warmer, more natural tones (such as wood-like finishes) to better align with the "traditional, natural, and sustainable" design guidelines outlined in the IVOD. • Roof Form: The design features a sloped roof at a 2:12 ratio. Since the IVOD code requires street-facing roof slopes between 5:12 and 12:12, the applicant acknowledged they will need to seek a variance from the ZBA. • The Board suggested that they would be looking closely at building materials and colors and any maximum lot coverage in the IVOD design standards. PB Resolution 2026-009: SEQR Lead Agency – Declaration of Intent Plumbers & Steamfitters Joint Apprentice Training Center Elmira Road 35.-1-10.2 & 35.-1-9.21 Whereas: 1. The Town of Ithaca Planning Board, at its meeting on September 1, 2026, considered a Sketch Plan for the proposed Plumbers and Steamfitters (Local 81 Union) new Joint Apprentice Training Center building project, located on Elmira Road, between Enfield Falls Road and Park Lane, in the Low Density Residential Zone and the Inlet Valley Overlay District (IVOD). The project involves constructing a +/- 23,700 square foot building on +/- 9 acres of land, along with parking facilities, outdoor training areas, a public walking trail, and other site plan elements. 2. The proposed project, which requires Site Plan approval and Special Permit by the Planning Board, is a Type I action pursuant to the State Environmental Quality Review Act, 6 NYCRR Part 617, and Chapter 148 of the Town of Ithaca Code regarding Environmental Quality Review, because the proposal involves “any Unlisted action, that exceeds 25 percent of any Page 1070 PB 2026-09-01 (Filed 9/25) Pg. 10 threshold in this section, occurring wholly or partially within or substantially contiguous to any publicly owned or operated parkland, recreation area or designated open space, including any site on the Register of National Natural Landmarks pursuant to 36 CFR part 62 (which is incorporated by reference pursuant to section 617.17 of this Part),” as noted in 617.4(b)(10). 3. A Full Environmental Assessment Form, Part 1, has been submitted by the applicant, along with a report containing a narrative and studies titled “Plumbers and Steamfitters Local 81 Joint Apprenticeship Training Center Sketch Plan Review Application Project Summary,” dated July 20, 2026, prepared by Brian Manthey Architect, drawings titled “PLUMBERS & STEAMFITTERS LOCAL 81 JATC Joint Apprentice Training Center,” dated July 20, 2026, prepared by Keplinger Freeman Associates, and other materials; now, therefor e be it Resolved: That the Town of Ithaca Planning Board hereby proposes to establish itself as Lead Agency to coordinate the environmental review of the proposed actions, as described above, and be it Further Resolved: That the Town of Ithaca Planning Board hereby requests the concurrence of all involved agencies on this proposed Lead Agency designation, said concurrence to be received by the Town of Ithaca Planning Department by October 1, 2026. Moved: Jenni Minner Seconded: Liz Bageant Vote: ayes – Minner, Bageant, Cameron, Ferrara, Reynolds, and McGurk 4. Continue to consider a recommendation to the Town Board regarding proposed amendments to Town Code, Chapter 234, Subdivision of Land. 5. Approval of Minutes – Motion by Ms. Bageant, seconded by Ms. Minner to approve the minutes of August 4, 2026, as submitted; unanimous. 6. Other Business • Upcoming Agenda Preview (September 15, 2026): • South Works project (Public Works Committee in the morning; preliminary site plan and subdivision review in the evening) • Short-term rental special permit (130 Forest Home Drive) • Cornell University Beebe Hall renovations on Arboretum Road The meeting was adjourned upon motion and a second, unanimous. Submitted by Paulette Rosa, Town Clerk Page 1071 PB 2026-09-15 (Filed 9/28) Pg. 1 TOWN OF ITHACA PLANNING BOARD September 15, 2026 DRAFT MINUTES The full video recording of this meeting is available on YouTube @TownofIthacaVideo (Written comments submitted at the meeting or after posting of the official mailout packet and 24 hours after the meeting can be found in the updated packet online and will be filed permanently with the project folder along with any other comments received after the post meeting deadline.) Present: Caitlin Cameron, Chair; Bill Arms, Sara Reynolds, Vincent Ferrara and Kelda McGurk (via videoconferencing per Town Policy) Absent - Liz Bageant CJ Randall, Director of Planning, Christine Balestra, Senior Planner and Nick Quilty-Koval, Planner; Nate VanWhy, Attorney for the Town; Dana Magnuson, Senior Code Officer; Justin McNeal, Director of Engineering and Emily Rodgers, Engineer; Paulette Rosa, Town Clerk Ms. Cameron called the meeting to order and noted for the record that the 130 Forest Home Dr item(s) had been pulled. 1. Persons to be heard – None 2. PUBLIC HEARING: SEQR and Consideration of a Special Permit for a Short-term rental located at 130 Forest Home Drive. The Town Board rezoned this property in 2023 by superimposing a Limited Historic Commercial Overlay District over the base Medium Density Residential Zone, which allows the Short-term rental use for one unit in the principal building, following Special Permit approval by the Planning Board. This is an Unlisted Action under the State Environmental Quality Review Act and is subject to environmental review. Lirong (Vicky) Wu, Owner/Applicant. 3. Consideration of Preliminary & Final Site Plan and Special Permit Approval for the proposed Cornell University Beebe Hall Maker Hub Renovation project, located at 110 Arboretum Road, between Forest Home Drive and Judd Falls Road, in the Low Density Residential Zone. The project involves a 350 s.f. building addition for increased pedestrian access to the existing building, a new outdoor porch area, new rooftop equipment, and other building and site modifications. This is a Type II Action under the State Environmental Quality Review Act and is not subject to an environmental review. Travis Fisher, Applicant; Cornell University, Owner. Project Scope Presented by Leslie Schill (Director of Campus Planning) and Jim Yarborough (College Facilities): Page 1072 PB 2026-09-15 (Filed 9/28) Pg. 2 • Purpose: Renovate the existing facility at Beebe Hall into a “Maker Hub,” a centralized hub for 3D printing, woodworking, metalworking, and media/clay studios available to students across all disciplines. • Physical Scope: Construct a 350 sq. ft. southern entrance addition designed to improve pedestrian flow, alongside internal system upgrades and elevator modernizations. • Sustainability: The project is targeting LEED Silver certification. • Site Work: Construct a new outdoor porch, remove several trees and bushes, install new rooftop HVAC equipment, relocate an electrical transformer, install new a new dumpster enclosure, reconfigure the parking lot to maintain 18 spaces, and building-wide window surround painting. Sidewalk Alternatives The Board evaluated two proposals for pedestrian connectivity as shown on Sheet L201 of the site plans entitled “Beebe Hall CU Maker Hub Renovations,” dated August 21, 2026: • Alternative 1 (shown as Red Alternative at the meeting): A sidewalk on the same (southern) side of Arboretum Road from the eastern entryway of Beebe Hall to an existing trail south of the project area. • Alternative 2 (shown as Blue Alternative at the meeting): A sidewalk on the opposite (northern) side of Arboretum Road from the Cornell Botanical Garden parking lot to a trail located south of Forest Home Drive. The Board expressed a strong preference for the Red Alternative. Deliberation highlighted that the Red Alternate connects more logically to the existing path leading toward Mann Library and the Botanic Gardens. Conversely, the Blue Alternate would require pedestrians to cross to a dirt trail that is difficult to navigate, particularly for students carrying equipment. Public Hearing Ms. Cameron opened the public hearing; there was no one wishing to speak and the hearing was closed. Determination Mr. Moseley noted that the Town is not the entity having jurisdiction over the building permit(s) for this project, just design review by the Planning Board. The Board discussed the draft resolution and conditions: • Lighting: Submission of cut sheets for the proposed five bollard lights (under 4 feet tall). • Structural: Provision of dimensions for retaining walls and site details on sheets L201 and L502. • Architectural: Submission of all four building elevations for the record. • Engineering: Submission of a basic Stormwater Pollution Prevention Plan (SWPPP) and a final site plan reflecting the selected sidewalk design (per revised Condition B). PB Resolution 2026-010: Preliminary & Final Site Plan Approval, Special Permit Cornell University Beebe Hall Maker Hub Renovations Page 1073 PB 2026-09-15 (Filed 9/28) Pg. 3 110 Arboretum Road Tax Parcel 67.-1-13.2 Whereas: 1. Consideration of Preliminary & Final Site Plan and Special Permit Approval for the proposed Cornell University Beebe Hall Maker Hub Renovation project, located at 110 Arboretum Road, between Forest Home Drive and Judd Falls Road, in the Low Density Residential Zone. The project involves a 350 square foot building addition for increased pedestrian access to the existing building, a new outdoor porch area, new rooftop equipment, and other building and site modifications. This is a Type II Action under the State Environmental Quality Review Act and is not subject to an environmental review. Travis Fisher, Applicant; Cornell University, Owner, 2. In accordance with 6 NYCRR State Environmental Quality Review, §617.5 (c)(9) “construction or expansion of a primary or accessory/appurtenant, nonresidential structure or facility involving less than 4,000 square feet of gross floor area and not involving a change in zoning or a use variance and consistent with local land use controls, but not radio communication or microwave transmission facilities;” §617.5(c)(10) “routine activities of educational institutions, including expansion of existing facilities by less than 10,000 square feet of gross floor area and school closings, but not changes in use related to such closings;” and §617.5(c)(18), “reuse of a residential or commercial structure, or of a structure containing mixed residential and commercial uses, where the residential or commercial use is a permitted use under the applicable zoning law or ordinance, including permitted by special use permit, and the action does not meet or exceeds any of the thresholds in section 617.4 of this Part” are Type II Actions and are therefore not subject to further environmental review, and 3. The Planning Board, at a public hearing held on September 15, 2026, has reviewed and accepted as adequate a narrative and a set of drawings entitled “Beebe Hall CU Maker Hub Renovations,” including Sheets C200, C300, C400, L101, L201, L301, L401, L501, L502, prepared by Fisher Associates, dated August 21, 2021, and other application materials, now, therefore be it Resolved: 1. That the Planning Board hereby finds that the Special Permit standards of Article XXIV Section 270-200, Subsections A – H, of the Town of Ithaca Code, have been met, specifically that: A. The project will be suitable for the property on which it is proposed, considering the property’s size, location, and physical site characteristics. • The adaptive reuse project is located on Cornell University property and maintains the existing building footprint with minor modifications to site parking, installation of sidewalks, and removal and replacement of landscaping. Page 1074 PB 2026-09-15 (Filed 9/28) Pg. 4 B. The proposed structure design and site layout are compatible with the surrounding area. • The proposed exterior modifications to existing buildings with updated materials are complementary to the university’s architectural vernacular. C. Operations in connection with the proposed use do not create any more noise, fumes, vibration, illumination, or other potential nuisances than the operation of any permitted use in the particular zone. • The proposed project will produce temporary noise, vibration, and other nuisances associated with constructing new architectural features, painting, construction new parking spaces, and installing new pedestrian walkways. Such nuisances will cease upon completion of the project. D. Community infrastructure and services, such as police, fire and other protective services, roadways, schools, and water and sewer facilities are currently, or will be, of adequate capacity to accommodate the proposed use. • The project does not include modifications to existing community infrastructure and services are of adequate capacity to accommodate the proposed use. E. The proposed use, structure design, and site layout comply with all the provisions of the Town Code and with the Town of Ithaca Comprehensive Plan. F. The site layout, with proposed vehicular, bicycle and pedestrian access, traffic circulation, and parking and loading facilities, is sufficient for the proposed use and is safely designed for emergency vehicles. • This project includes minor modifications to construction two additional parking spaces along the northern parking area and construction of new asphalt pavement areas located adjacent to a proposed overhead door. All accessways have been designed with consideration for emergency vehicles G. The project includes sufficient landscaping and/or other forms of buffering to protect surrounding land uses. Existing vegetation is preserved to the extent possible. • The project includes the removal of four bushes and four saplings at 110 Arboretum Road. The project also includes the removal of six evergreen trees across the street on Arboretum Road to support the construction of a new pedestrian sidewalk. The project includes a planting plan detailing foundational plantings around the existing building and new trees and shrubs located around the site. H. To the extent deemed relevant by the reviewing Board, the proposed use or structure complies with all the criteria applicable to site plan review set forth in this chapter, and be it Further Resolved: Page 1075 PB 2026-09-15 (Filed 9/28) Pg. 5 1. That the Town of Ithaca Planning Board hereby waives certain requirements for Preliminary and Final Site Plan Approval, as shown on the Preliminary & Final Site Plan Checklists, having determined from the materials presented that such waiver will result in a significant alteration of neither the purpose of site plan control nor the policies enunciated or implied by the Town Board; and 2. That the Town of Ithaca Planning Board hereby grants Preliminary & Final Site Plan Approval and Special Permit for the proposed Cornell University Beebe Hall Maker Hub Renovations, as described in the materials listed in Whereas #3 above, subject to the following conditions: a That the applicant submit cut sheets and a lighting plan containing details for the proposed building mounted lighting and illuminated bollards; b Submission of a revised site plan (Sheet L201) and site details (Sheet L502) detailing proposed retaining walls, including dimensions and materials used for said feature, and site plans depicting the selected sidewalk design alternative and contract limit line alternate; c Submission of architectural sheets that depict all four building elevations, including proposed building materials and colors, location of outdoor lighting fixtures, and proposed “overhead structure” located on the northern portion of the building, as noted on the site plan (Sheet L201); d Submission for review and approval by the Town Engineering Department a Basic SWPPP Moved: Bill Arms Seconded: Vincent Ferrara Vote: ayes- Arms, Ferrara, Cameron, Minner and McGurk 4. Consideration of Preliminary Site Plan and Preliminary Subdivision Approval for the SouthWorks Woods project located off NYS Route 96B/Danby Road, in Town of Ithaca Planned Development Zone No.16. The SouthWorks Woods mixed-income residential project comprises a 6.09-acre portion of the overall SouthWorks (formerly Chain Works District) Redevelopment Project, and involves the construction of eight residential buildings with a total of 130 mixed-income apartments, including a community room, lounge, fitness center, offices, maintenance areas, and storage. The Woods project also involves the development of internal roads and infrastructure, a playground, sidewalks and path connections, stormwater facilities, landscaping, outdoor lighting, parking, and other site improvements. Shift Chainworks Owner 1 LLC, Owner; Beacon Communities, LLC, Applicant; James Gensel, Fagan Engineers & Land Surveyors, PC, Agent. Updates from the Applicants The applicant (Beacon Communities/Fagan Engineers/SWBR) presented several revisions: Infrastructure and Site Updates • Road B/Drive V: Widened to a 60-foot Right-of-Way (ROW) per Town standards. Page 1076 PB 2026-09-15 (Filed 9/28) Pg. 6 • Amenities: Addition of bike racks at the mansion apartments and the ride-share location. • Materials: Adoption of fiber cement board-and-batten for the ground level to increase durability. • Request to provide 100% secondary cladding materials for buildings C1, C2, and C3 instead of 60% primary and 40% secondary cladding. Traffic Study The Board is awaiting the results of a third-party traffic study conducted by Tim Faulkner of Fisher Associates, who was involved in the 2017 pedestrian study of the 96B corridor. Coordination with NYS DOT Region 3 is ongoing to finalize safety measures at the Danby Road/Coddington Road intersection. Facade Material Deviation The Board engaged in a detailed debate regarding the use of corrugated metal as a primary cladding material (comprising 42–43% of the facade), as it is only permitted as a secondary cladding material per the PDZ requirements Concerns regarding the "institutional" and "monolithic" feel of the metal expanses compared to the "human-scale" requirements of the Zoning Code were discussed. Discussion regarding whether the Board has to find the applicant has met its burden of demonstrating a superior alternative, as required in Section 271 7F. The alternative details and a letter from the applicant were submitted to the Board, demonstrating, in their opinion, that the proposals are superior alternatives to the primary cladding materials listed in the PDZ. Motion to approve the use as presented by the applicant as of September 15, 2026, with corrugated metal as the primary siding material instead of a design that follows the design guidelines outlined in section 271-17 (F) (6) (d) because the applicant has met its burden of demonstrating why the design is a superior alternative to a design that follows those guidelines for the reasons set forth in their submittal from SWBR dated August 19th, 2026 and because of the industrial nature of the existing site and the apartment building's location being set back on the residential street context. Moved by Jenni Minner, seconded by Bill Arms. Vote: Aye – Cameron, Arms and Minner Nay – McGurk and Ferrara Motion failed. Lengthy discussion followed, with the Board expressing various ways the applicant could break up the expanse and mitigate the look of the corrugated metal. A revised motion was made: Motion to approve the use, as presented by the applicant as of September 15, 2026, of only secondary siding materials for 100% of the cladding materials instead of a design that follows Page 1077 PB 2026-09-15 (Filed 9/28) Pg. 7 the design guidelines outlined in section 271-17(F)(6)(d) because the applicant has met its burden of demonstrating why the design is a superior alternative to a design that follows those guidelines, for the reasons set forth in their submittal from SWBR, dated August 19, 2026, and because of the industrial nature of the existing site and the apartment buildings' location being set back from the residential street context. This is conditioned on the inclusion of a design strategy that breaks up the corrugated siding using articulation, change of material, revision to the ratio of openings, or similar design strategy within each expanse of corrugated metal on each of the long facades of the buildings C1, C2, and C3 to meet the desired characteristic of the subarea to have human-scaled details or materials. Moved by Vinnie Ferrara, seconded by Jenni Minner. Vote: Aye – Cameron, Arms and Minner, McGurk and Ferrara Nays – None Motion passed. PB Resolution: 2026-011 Preliminary Site Plan, Subdivision Approval The Woods at SouthWorks Residential Development NYS Route 96B/Danby Road Tax Parcel No. 40.-3-3 Whereas: 1. This action is the consideration of Preliminary Site Plan and Preliminary Subdivision Approval for the SouthWorks Woods project located off NYS Route 96B/Danby Road, in Town of Ithaca Planned Development Zone No.16. The SouthWorks Woods mixed-income residential project comprises a 6.09-acre portion of the overall SouthWorks (formerly Chain Works District) Redevelopment Project and involves the construction of eight residential buildings with a total of 130 mixed-income apartments, including a community room, lounge, fitness center, offices, maintenance areas, and storage. The Woods project also involves the development of internal roads and infrastructure, a playground, sidewalks and path connections, stormwater facilities, landscaping, outdoor lighting, parking, and other site improvements. Shift Chainworks Owner 1 LLC, Owner; Beacon Communities, LLC, Applicant; James Gensel, Fagan Engineers & Land Surveyors, PC, Agent; 2. The overall SouthWorks (formerly Chain Works District) Redevelopment Project is located on a 95-acre parcel traversing the City and Town of Ithaca’s municipal boundary. It is a proposed mixed-use development consisting of residential, office, commercial, retail, restaurant/café, warehousing/distribution, manufacturing, and open space. The City of Ithaca, as the Lead Agency in the environmental review of the South Works (formerly Chain Works District) Redevelopment Project, issued a Findings Statement for the GEIS on March 26, 2019; 3. The Town of Ithaca, as an Involved Agency in the environmental review of the SouthWorks (formerly Chain Works District) Redevelopment Project, issued a Findings Statement for the Page 1078 PB 2026-09-15 (Filed 9/28) Pg. 8 GEIS on May 21, 2019. The Findings Statement included a threshold condition chart and checklist for future site-specific projects associated with the overall development; 4. The Town of Ithaca Planning Board, as the Lead Agency in the environmental review of The Woods at SouthWorks project, at their meeting on August 18, 2026, determined that The Woods at SouthWorks project did not exceed the threshold conditions outlined in the SouthWorks (formerly Chain Works District) Redevelopment Project GEIS Findings Statement, and that the Woods at SouthWorks project did not require additional environmental review. The Board reviewed and accepted as adequate a completed GEIS threshold checklist and Part 3 EAF, prepared by Town staff, dated July 28, 2026 (revised August 11, 2026), along with a project narrative with twenty-one (21) attachments, including: a visual impact analysis; a letter from LaBella Associates, dated June 24, 2026, regarding soil vapor intrusion mitigation; correspondence between the applicant and Marty Moseley, Director of Code Enforcement, regarding fire apparatus configuration and Code requirements; a letter from Fagan Engineers & Land Surveyors, D.P.C., dated July 20, 2026, regarding Transportation Demand Management (TDM) plans; two letters from LaBella Associates, one dated June 29, 2026, regarding traffic assessment, and one dated August 3, 2026, regarding traffic signal warrant and left-turn lane assessment; a Stormwater Pollution Prevention Plan, prepared by Fagan Engineers & Land Surveyors, D.P.C., revised July 2026; a Geotechnical Evaluation, prepared by Foundation Design, P.C., dated March 10, 2026; an Excavation Plan, prepared by Pike; a letter from Timothy Faulkner, P.E., Fisher Associates, D.P.C. dated July 28, 2026, regarding SouthWorks Beacon Woods transportation assessment; Site Plan Drawings titled “Beacon Communities, The Woods at SouthWorks, Town of Ithaca, Tompkins County, New York,” prepared by SWBR, dated August 14, 2024, most recently revised August 10, 2026, including sheets C100, C200, C300, C301 through C306, C400 through C407, C500 through C505, C600, C601, C700 through C702, C800 through C802, C900, and C901; Site Plan and Architectural Renderings, prepared by SWBR (no date); Exterior Elevations and Detail sheets, prepared by SWBR, dated June 12, 2026, including sheets A201-A, A201-B1, A202-B2, A203-B3, A201-C1, A202-C2, and A203-C3; Layout and Materials plans, prepared by SWBR, dated June 12, 2026, revised June 29, 2026, including sheets L-101 through L-104; Planting Plans, prepared by SWBR, dated June 12, 2026, including sheets L-401 through L-405; Lighting Plans, prepared by SWBR, dated June 12, 2026, revised June 29, 2026, including sheets L-301 through L-307; Construction Phasing Plan, titled “The Woods Draft Phasing and Logistics Plan,” dated 6-29-26; and other materials; 5. At a Public Hearing held on August 18, 2026, the Planning Board reviewed, and accepted as adequate additional project information, including a letter from Fagan Engineering, dated July 7, 2026 (updated August 18, 2026), regarding stream setback mitigation; a letter from SWBR, dated August 10, 2026, regarding cladding materials in compliance with Town Code §271-17 (F)(6)(d); a letter from Beacon Communities, LLC, dated August 10, 2026, regarding Center for Community Transportation/TCAT Engagement; and revised site plan materials noted in #4 (most recent revision date of August 10, 2026); 6. At an additional meeting held on September 15, 2026, the Planning Board reviewed, and accepted as adequate revised project information, including a letter from SWBR to Caitlin Page 1079 PB 2026-09-15 (Filed 9/28) Pg. 9 Cameron, Planning Board Chair, dated 8/19/2026, regarding architectural cladding materials and façade design; revised Site Plan, Architectural Renderings, and example photos of other large apartment complexes with similar proposed cladding, prepared by SWBR (no date); revised Sheet C901 (Stream Mitigation Exhibit), showing specific plantings and stream mitigation, prepared by SWBR, dated 09/01/2026; proposed lighting and site amenity cut sheets, including Sheets L503-L508, prepared by SWBR, dated June 12, 2026; and a revised subdivision plat showing a 60-foot right of way along Road B/Drive V, prepared by SWBR, dated 09/01/2026; 7. Project plans, and related information, were duly delivered to the Tompkins County Planning and Sustainability Department per New York State General Municipal Law §§239- l et seq., and such Department responded in an August 14, 2026, letter from Katherine Borgella, Tompkins County Commissioner of Planning, pursuant to §§239-l, -m, and -n of the New York State General Municipal Law, determining that the proposed action will not have significant county-wide or inter-community impact; now, therefore, be it Resolved: That the Town of Ithaca Planning Board hereby grants Preliminary Site Plan and Preliminary Subdivision Approval for the proposed The Woods at SouthWorks, as described in the materials listed in Whereas numbers 4, 5, and 6 above, subject to the following conditions, to be met: Before final site plan/final subdivision approval: a. Receipt of any necessary variances from the Zoning Board of Appeals, b. Approval from the Town of Ithaca Director of Code Enforcement that all fire flow calculations are in accordance with New York State Fire Code, and that all fire access issues listed in the memo from Marty Moseley, Director of Code Enforcement, dated 7/21/26, have been satisfied (memo attached), c. Approval by the Town Board of the concept and location of any proposed dedicated public utilities (water, sewer) and infrastructure (roads, streetlights, sidewalks, etc.), and proposed easements associated with such utilities and infrastructure, d. Coordination with all utility companies (including NYSEG and Verizon) to assure that they have no concerns associated with the project’s connection to the electrical grid, with the burying of utility lines, or with other project elements, e. Submission of letters of commitment from local bikeshare and carshare services that they will locate bicycles and vehicles, respectively, on the project site, and from Tompkins Consolidated Area Transit, Inc. (TCAT) that it intends to serve the project site, Before issuance of a Building Permit: Page 1080 PB 2026-09-15 (Filed 9/28) Pg. 10 f. Satisfaction of all comments identified in the memorandum prepared by Barton and Loguidice to Justin McNeal, Town Director of Engineering, dated August 10, 2026 (memo attached), g. Submission, review, execution, and filing of an Operation, Maintenance and Reporting agreement for the proposed stormwater management facilities, with the Town of Ithaca, specifying the ownership and maintenance responsibilities for the stormwater system, including: (i) Submission of an access easement, or other mechanism, to assure Town of Ithaca access to the stormwater facilities, (ii) Review and approval of the access easement and the Operation, Maintenance, and Reporting Agreement by the Attorney for the Town and the Town Engineer, and (iii)Town Board authorization to allow the Town Supervisor to sign any necessary easements and the Stormwater Operation, Maintenance, and Reporting Agreement associated with the project, h. Submission of an approved Highway Work Permit (Commercial Driveway Access Permit and/or Utility Permits, as applicable) from the New York State Department of Transportation (NYSDOT) for improvements within the NYS Route 96B/Danby Road right-of-way. The Town should be made aware of any additional plan modifications that may be required by the NYSDOT, as well as any resultant impacts to the current site plan, i. Submission for signing by the Chairperson of the Planning Board of an original and three dark lined prints of the final subdivision plat, prior to filing with the Tompkins County Clerk Office; and submission of a copy of the receipt of filing to the Planning Department, j. Dedication to and acceptance by the Town Board, of any proposed public utilities (water, sewer), and infrastructure (roads, streetlights, sidewalks, etc.), and proposed easements associated with such utilities and infrastructure, k. Per the NYS Department of Environmental Conservation’s (DEC) Record of Decision Declaration of Covenants and Restrictions, submission of proof that the former NCR and Ithaca College sewer lines have been evaluated for potential soil vapor intrusion, Before issuance of any Certificate of Occupancy: l. If required, mitigation of any potential soil vapor intrusion of the former NCR and Ithaca College sewer lines, and submission of proof from the NYS DEC and/or NYS Department of Health (DOH) that said mitigation was in accordance with DEC and DOH requirements, m. Completion of all requirements of the NYS DOT, including construction of the sidewalk along the west side of Danby Road/NYS Route 96B to the City of Ithaca line, and including any temporary measures at the intersection of Coddington Road and Danby Road/NYS Route 96B, and Page 1081 PB 2026-09-15 (Filed 9/28) Pg. 11 n. Submission of any required executed easements, licenses, or other legal agreements involving Town or City property, for review and approval by the Attorney for the Town. Moved: Vinnie Ferrara Seconded: Jenni Minner Vote: ayes – Minner, Arms, Cameron, McGurk and Ferrara 5. Continue to consider a recommendation to the Town Board regarding proposed amendments to Town Code, Chapter 234, Subdivision of Land - Postponed The Board was not in favor of making a final decision on the recommendation to the Town Board but did again discuss certain points of the draft rules for cluster subdivisions, including the 40% open space requirement, noting that there will be more opportunities for discussion with the full Board prior to acting. Key Discussion Points • Mapping Context: Staff clarified that these new regulations are intended for low-density residential and conservation areas and do not apply to high-density Traditional Neighborhood Development (TND) or New Neighborhood Code zones like SouthWorks. • Classification Logic: Ms. Minner questioned the percentages for historic and conservation lands, requesting more clarity on how these were decided upon and how they are weighed. • Design Language: The Chair recommended striking the clause regarding "exterior characteristics" from section 234-21 to avoid unnecessary design prescription. 6. Approval of Minutes – None 7. Other Business Planning Staff reviewed the agendas for the next meeting. The meeting was adjourned upon a motion and a second, unanimous. Submitted by Paulette Rosa Town Clerk Page 1082 PB 2026-08-18 (Filed 8/26) Pg. 1 TOWN OF ITHACA PLANNING BOARD August 18, 2026 MINUTES A courtesy recording of this meeting is available on YouTube@TownofIthacaVideo (Written comments submitted at the meeting or after posting of the official mailout packet and 24 hours after the meeting can be found in the updated packet online and will be filed permanently with the project folder along with any other comments received after the post meeting deadline.) Present: Caitlin Cameron, Chair; Liz Bageant, Vincent Ferrara, and Sara Reynolds Absent: Jenni Minner, Bill Arms, Kelda McGurk Christine Balestra, Senior Planner; Justin McNeal, Director of Engineering; Marty Moseley, Director of Code Enforcement; C.J. Randall, Director of Planning; Paulette Rosa, Town Clerk and Nate VanWhy, Attorney for the Town. Ms. Cameron opened the meeting at 6:31 p.m. 1. Persons to be heard – None 2. SEQR Determination: The Woods at SouthWorks – NYS Route 96B/Danby Road Introduction Jamie Gensel (Fagan Engineers) and Steven Pete (SWBR) provided updated presentations and civil engineering data regarding the project. • Stormwater & Sewer Updates: Jamie Gensel reported on the ongoing item-by-item review of stormwater comments with the Town Engineer. Because of the site's steep slopes, sanitary sewer updates will include 'trap manholes' to maintain flow and prevent solids from settling. • Traffic Driveway Filings: The applicant submitted driveway permit applications to the NYS Department of Transportation (DOT) for the mansion apartment driveway, a private driveway, and Driveway 5 (the primary entrance road), hoping to expedite state agency review. • Architectural Cladding Swap: Steven Pete presented materials and colors for the proposed cladding modification, reducing the corrugated metal cladding on the apartment buildings down to 40%. The corrugated metal at grade/first story is swapped with highly durable, horizontal fiber cement (Pura or Hardie Board shiplap format) to prevent denting. Mr. Pete highlighted that this cladding system allows an uninterrupted layer of continuous exterior insulation from the footing to the parapet, creating a robust thermal envelope that meets energy code enhancements. • Stream Setback Mitigation: Revised materials were presented highlighting stream impacts. Stream A (which carries drainage from Ithaca College) will have 4,200 square feet of pavement crossing and DRAFT DRAFT Page 1083 PB 2026-08-18 (Filed 8/26) Pg. 2 266 square feet of Building C1 footprint in its outer setback. Earthwork inside the Stream B setback is limited to 540 square feet of pavement and earthwork. Retaining walls were relocated to minimize impacts and avoid bringing them to the street level. SEQR Determination Minor changes were made to the draft SEQR Form and resolution. PB RESOLUTION 2026-006: SEQR Determination The Woods at SouthWorks Residential Development NYS Route 96B/Danby Road Tax Parcel No. 40.-3-3 WHEREAS: 1. This action is the Consideration of Preliminary Site Plan Approval for the SouthWorks Woods project located off NYS Route 96B/Danby Road, in Town of Ithaca Planned Development Zone No.16. The Town of Ithaca Planning Board is the Lead Agency in the environmental review with respect to the proposed site-specific SouthWorks Woods mixed-income residential project, which comprises a portion of the overall SouthWorks (formerly Chain Works District) Redevelopment Project, and involves the construction of eight residential buildings with a total of 130 mixed-income apartments, including a community room, lounge, fitness center, offices, maintenance areas, and storage. The Woods project also involves the development of internal roads and infrastructure, a playground, sidewalks and path connections, stormwater facilities, landscaping, outdoor lighting, parking, and other site improvements. The Town of Ithaca Planning Board will first determine if the project exceeds the threshold conditions that were outlined in the GEIS Findings Statement, therefore requiring additional or supplemental environmental review. The board will then consider Preliminary Site Plan Approval for the project. Shift Chainworks Owner 1 LLC, Owner; Beacon Communities, LLC, Applicant; James Gensel, Fagan Engineers & Land Surveyors, PC, Agent; 2. The overall SouthWorks (formerly Chain Works District) Redevelopment Project is located on a 95- acre parcel traversing the City and Town of Ithaca’s municipal boundary. It is a proposed mixed-use development consisting of residential, office, commercial, retail, restaurant/café, warehousing/distribution, manufacturing, and open space. The City of Ithaca, as the Lead Agency in the environmental review of the Chain Works District Redevelopment Project, issued a Findings Statement for the GEIS on March 26, 2019; 3. The Town of Ithaca, as an Involved Agency in the environmental review of the SouthWorks (formerly Chain Works District) Redevelopment Project, issued a Findings Statement for the GEIS on May 21, 2019. The Findings Statement included a threshold condition chart and checklist for future site-specific projects associated with the overall development; 4. The Town of Ithaca Planning Board, at their meetings on August 4, 2026, and August 18, 2026, have reviewed and accepted as adequate a project narrative with twenty-one (21) attachments, including: a visual impact analysis; a letter from LaBella, dated June 24, 2026, regarding soil vapor intrusion mitigation; correspondence between the applicant and Marty Moseley, Director of Code Page 1084 PB 2026-08-18 (Filed 8/26) Pg. 3 Enforcement, regarding fire apparatus configuration and Code requirements; a letter from Fagan Engineers, dated July 20, 2026, regarding Transportation Demand Management (TDM) plans; two letters from LaBella, one dated June 29, 2026, regarding traffic assessment, and one dated August 3, 2026, regarding traffic signal warrant and left-turn lane assessment; a letter from Fagan Engineering, dated July 7, 2026 (update August 10, 2026), regarding stream setback mitigation; a letter from SWBR, dated August 10, 2026, regarding cladding materials in compliance with Town Code §271- 17 (F)(6)(d); a letter from Beacon Communities, dated August 10, 2026, regarding Center for Community Transportation/TCAT Engagement; a Stormwater Pollution Prevention Plan, prepared by Fagan Engineers, revised July 2026; a Geotechnical Evaluation, prepared by Foundation Design, P.C., dated March 10, 2026; an Excavation Plan, prepared by Pike; a letter from Timothy Faulkner, Fisher Associates, dated July 28, 2026, regarding SouthWorks Beacon Woods transportation assessment; Site Plan Drawings titled “Beacon Communities, The Woods at SouthWorks, Town of Ithaca, Tompkins County, New York,” prepared by SWBR, dated August 14, 2024, most recently revised August 10, 2026, including sheets C100, C200, C300, C301 through C306, C400 through C407, C500 through C505, C600, C601, C700 through C702, C800 through C802, C900, and C901; Site Plan and Architectural Renderings, prepared by SWBR (no date); Exterior Elevations and Detail sheets, prepared by SWBR, dated June 12, 2026, including sheets A201-A, A201-B1, A202-B2, A203-B3, A201-C1, A202-C2, and A203-C3; Layout and Materials plans, prepared by SWBR, dated June 12, 2026, revised June 29, 2026, including sheets L-101 through L-104; Planting Plans, prepared by SWBR, dated June 12, 2026, including sheets L-401 through L-405; Lighting Plans, prepared by SWBR, dated June 12, 2026, revised June 29, 2026, including sheets L-301 through L- 307; Construction Phasing Plan, titled “The Woods Draft Phasing and Logistics Plan,” dated 6-29- 26; and other materials (collectively, “Application Materials”); 5. The Town of Ithaca Planning Board, as the Lead Agency for The Woods at SouthWorks project, has reviewed the GEIS threshold conditions, a completed GEIS threshold checklist and Part 3 EAF, prepared by Town staff; NOW THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED: That the Town of Ithaca Planning Board hereby finds the following: 1. The Application Materials submitted for The Woods project have demonstrated that deviating from the strict sequence envisioned in the GEIS for Phase 1 allows a more thoughtful and flexible development phasing to meet market demands and allows construction of mixed-income housing sooner; 2. The Woods at SouthWorks project does not exceed the threshold conditions outlined in the SouthWorks (formerly Chain Works District) Redevelopment Project GEIS Findings Statement, based on the GEIS threshold conditions outlined in the Findings Statement, the GEIS checklist attachment and Part 3 EAF prepared by Town staff, dated July 28, 2026, revised August 11, 2026, and the reasons stated above. Therefore, The Woods at SouthWorks project does not require additional environmental review; and 3. The Applicants shall, prior to the Town of Ithaca Planning Board proceeding with the review of other site specific projects within the SouthWorks Redevelopment Project area, reinitiate review of Page 1085 PB 2026-08-18 (Filed 8/26) Pg. 4 the project with the New York State Department of Transportation (“NYSDOT”), and complete any supplemental traffic studies required by NYSDOT and Town of Ithaca Department of Public Works to allow the Town of Ithaca Planning Board and other involved and interested agencies to reassess traffic impacts along NYS Route 96B/Danby Road and affected local and County roads and potential modifications to traffic mitigation measures identified in the GEIS, given changes to NYS Route 96B/Danby Road done after completion of the GEIS. Moved: Sara Reynolds Seconded: Liz Bageant Vote: ayes – Reynolds, Bageant, Cameron and Ferrara 3. Consideration of Preliminary Site Plan and Preliminary Subdivision Approval for the SouthWorks Woods project located off NYS Route 96B/Danby Road, in Town of Ithaca Planned Development Zone No.16. The Town of Ithaca Planning Board is the Lead Agency in the environmental review with respect to the proposed site-specific SouthWorks Woods mixed-income residential project, which comprises a 6.09-acre portion of the overall SouthWorks (formerly Chain Works District) Redevelopment Project, and involves the construction of eight residential buildings with a total of 130 mixed-income apartments, including a community room, lounge, fitness center, offices, maintenance areas, and storage. The Woods project also involves the development of internal roads and infrastructure, a playground, sidewalks and path connections, stormwater facilities, landscaping, outdoor lighting, parking, and other site improvements. The Town of Ithaca Planning Board will first determine if the project exceeds the threshold conditions that were outlined in the GEIS Findings Statement, therefore requiring additional or supplemental environmental review. The board will then consider Preliminary Site Plan and Preliminary Subdivision Approval for the project. Shift Chainworks Owner 1 LLC, Owner; Beacon Communities, LLC, Applicant; James Gensel, Fagan Engineers & Land Surveyors, PC, Agent. Public Hearing – Ms. Cameron opened the public hearing; there was no one wishing to speak and the hearing was closed. Discussion The cladding material and palette are the primary outstanding issues. Under the Planned Development Zone (PDZ) guidelines, the corrugated metal cladding appears to act as the primary material on the C buildings, which does not align with the list of approved primary materials. Mr. Pete provided design justification, explaining that the lightweight metal panel allows a continuous thermal barrier with low embodied carbon, low global warming potential, and higher efficiency than masonry/EIFS, which cause severe thermal bridging. The Planning Board postponed the vote on preliminary site plan and subdivision approval to the September 1, 2026, meeting. To proceed, the applicant must submit: 1. Revised Architectural Plans & Renderings: Showing horizontal fiber cement siding (shiplap / Board & Batten style) on the ground floor of the buildings to replace the low-level corrugated metal. Page 1086 PB 2026-08-18 (Filed 8/26) Pg. 5 2. Written Justification: Formal presentation of the technical and energy efficiency rationale to satisfy the PDZ applicability clause for alternative designs. 3. Representative Photos: Provide visual references of other completed large apartment complexes utilizing the same metal cladding systems. 4. Revised Site Plan showing Bike Racks: Adding bicycle rack storage near the mansion apartments. Regarding the stream setback: Motion made by Liz Bageant, seconded by Vincent Ferrara, to recommend to the Town’s Zoning Board of Appeals approval of The Woods at SouthWorks proposed mitigation plan submitted in connection with a stream setback variance application (ZBAA-26-10), subject to the condition that a planting plan be submitted by the applicant and approved by the Town of Ithaca Planning Department prior to issuance of a building permit; unanimous. 4. Approval of Minutes - Motion by Ms. Reynolds, seconded by Ms. Bageant to accept the draft minutes of June 7th and 21st as final; unanimous 5. Other Business • Forestry Grants: The Town has submitted grant applications to the NYSDEC Urban and Community Forestry Program to develop forest management plans for the Town’s preserves. • Mini Map GIS Event: Scheduled for Saturday, September 26, 2026, from 10:30 AM to 2:00 PM at the Tompkins County Public Library. • Subdivision Regulation Workshop: October 1st, 4-9 PM at the Ithaca Conference Center. Prominent author Randall Arendt (writer of 'Rural by Design") will give a lecture and workshop, (approved for AICP continuing education credits) • Previewed upcoming Agendas The meeting was adjourned upon a motion and a second; unanimous. Submitted by Paulette Rosa Town Clerk Page 1087 lam writing in Support of the Special Permit for the Plumbers and Ele@gfric b. lf you have ever tried to find a trade worker to do something on vou us one wo b> realize we are in desperate need of trade workers and that is what Maey are ding,train .4,them,educating them AQ,»’Upp Union Clubs are not open to the public or acting as a commercial use makintem for sale/resale as listed in the Commercial uses in the overlay.“Gp/h The commercial uses which list the types of prohibited uses the person against this is relying on are for large scale commercial production or sale of products as the “use”of the business. The activities that may take place at the Union Club aka “shop”that have the same name are educational and training in nature and much,much smaller in scale than what a commercial entity would be doing,and therefore not a “use”but an educational “activity.” The “not mutually exclusive”terminology doesn’t apply because one would assume they apply to scale of use.It is a “use”prohibition,not an “activity”prohibition. |would suggest that the allowed use of “education”that is limited to k-12 be reviewed for a possible change to the overlay zoning to include the IV-T.Why are they not allowed?An event venue is allowed,that can have the same bulk and more traffic than this proposed use,|don’t understand the basis for not allowing other types of educational uses that do not involve the manufacturing or sale of products...a preschool like IC3 or Montessori;A pottery school;a gymnastics school?What is the impact the overlay is trying to avoid that is different from an “event venue’? mp eg 7)Private club/lodge OS of (S)J J ©J (S) Facility of a private club or organization,mn — mostly open only to club members and their guests.(Examples:service or lodge- based organization,social club,veterans’ club,labor union.) |don’t understand the measuring technique,but the combined parcels are almost 7 acres and it seems that the building footprint could cover up to 20%of that,or 1.4 acres,which | think is about 60K sqft,so the proposed 24k sqft is nowhere near that. They are also offering free parking and access to the trail system on many days and/or times which is a huge benefit to the public. Page 1088 An Open Letter to the Town Board Regarding the proposed Plumbers &Steamfitters Local 81 Joint Apprentice Training Center Tax parcels 35.-1-9.21 &35.-1-10.2,Elmira Road Planning Boardfiles DEV-26-8 /DEV-26-9 -ZBA ZBAI-26-1 Stan Hiller,Sunnygables -September 16,2026 ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS —REQUEST FOR INTERPRETATION ZBAI-26-1 Tuesday,September 22,2026,6:00 pm Townof Ithaca Town Hall,215 N.Tioga Street,Ithaca,NY 14850 Comments and questions may be emailed to codes@townithacany.gov up until 3:00 pm on the day of the meeting. Dear Town Board: In 2018,the Town adopted the I-VIP:Inlet Valley Ithaca Plan (IVP). Toward implementing that plan,the Inlet Valley Overlay District was created,including the Inlet Valley Transition (IV-T)zoning overlay —a zone the Towndescribes as intended to “serve as a transition and offer more limited commercial opportunities”,and which the Townlocates by reference to Sunnygables. My nameis Stan Hiller,and I've spent the last 28 months investing in the Town's Inlet Valley Plan by bringing a local landmark —that Gothic Revival building on 13,known variously as the old Turback's Restaurant or Sunnygables —back to life. It has been a journey.I'd genuinely love to tell you all about it,but that's for another time.For now,suffice it to say that when I bought it daylight could be seen not just through holes in the roof,but through holes in the tarps which had themselves spent too manyyears covering the holes in the roof.Folks had stolen all the copper out of the building;it had no plumbing,electric,or heat.I had the roof repaired.Restored utilities.It's now not only fully functional,but I've achieved net-zero energy use in this 1850s-built,5,500 sq ft building through efficient HVAC and a solar array. My investment in Sunnygables (which has been done underthe reasonable assumption that the Town would enforce the zoning laws they passed to define,protect,and preserve their articulated vision for the IVP)is about restoring a landmark and ensuring that the building itself is self- sustaining in a way that will ensure it never has to fall into such disrepair ever again;that it will be Page 1089 able to fund its own continued renovation and ongoing maintenance.The business plan revolves around making a building everyone loves accessible to the community,with rentable suites and indoor and outdoor space for weddings,family reunions,graduations,family holidays,etc.And the whole plan is,by design,either explicitly allowed by code or allowable with a special permit. I have no objection to a training center,nor to the Local 81 Joint Apprenticeship Training Committee building one.My objection is to anyone building a training and/or industrial facility on these parcels,where those uses are prohibited.The Ithaca Voice reportedthat I told the Planning Board this project did not belong in Inlet Valley.That was sloppy of me;what I wastrying to communicate is that the project as submitted is prohibited by the applicable zoning. This proposed 23,700 sq ft apprenticeship training facility?They're literally trying to build it directly next to where I'm aiming to have the outdoorevent venue.Dearreader...dear prospective event-hosting client...would you like to have your event next to an industrial training facility's dumpster?Say your vows next to their outdoor excavation practice area,with their crane-mounted rigging photo-bombing your wedding photos?Fancy your family reunion serenaded by the shrill BEEP-BEEP-BEEP of garbage trucks and tractor trailers backing up at their commercial loading dock?Is the nearby compressed (flammable/explosive)gas cylinder storage a compelling addition to the IVP? On December 23,2025,the Town's Director of Planning wrote that,after conferring with the Director of Code Enforcement &Zoning,“we concur that the proposed use —based on the details provided —is classified as”a private club/lodge under §270-171.5G(7).The details provided, earlier that same morning,were four lines:a 48,000 sq ft building,“educational use,”a NYS apprenticeship program,“joint use for meetings,”and 70-80 parking spaces.The plans filed seven months later include a 7,534 sq ft weld shop with an industrial air handler for dust and fume collection (baghouse),plumbing and pipefitter labs,an orbital welding classroom,a confined- space training pit,an outdoor gravel excavation pit,compressed-gas cylinder storage,a rigging yard,a loading dock,and seven offices.None of that was before the Town in December.The classification may have been right for the project as described,but it cannot possibly carry forward to the project as submitted.The parcels were purchased five months later,in May 2026,by the Plumbers &Steamfitters Local 81 Joint Apprenticeship Training Committee. The facts: —Noallowed use in the applicable IV-T overlay can accommodate an industrial and/ortrades- related training facility Page 1090 —Theonly times the [VOD names trade uses at all,it is to say they are not included in a specific, named,allowed use —trade uses,the code's own examples being “HVAC or plumbing service, machine shop,”are expressly not retail and service;and machine shops and uses related to building or mechanical trades are expressly not industrial arts studios.And the code's one industrial category —“industrial use:low impact,”meaning manufacture with no detectable offsite impacts —is not allowed in IV-T at all —Per the IVOD,each principal use must be considered as if it stands alone,even where it is functionally integrated with other uses;and uses are mutually exclusive,so a broadercategory does not absorb a more specific use that the tables list separately.The overlay's accessory-use table (§270-171.5I)contains only residential and agricultural accessories —no shops,no labs, no offices,no storage —so a prohibited use cannot become allowed bycalling it accessory to an allowed one —The applicant cannot decide either:its own project summaryclassifies the building as “a mixed-use Place of Assembly and Private Club/Lounge”—two separate civic categories claimed at once,which is precisely what the mutual-exclusivity rule forbids —while its architect classifies the occupancy as Business —And those twocategories are not interchangeable.Place of assembly(§270-171.5G(6)) expressly “includes typical ancillary uses”—the code's own examples being “meeting room, kitchen,exercise room,laundry room,workshop,day care center,offices.”Private club/lodge(§ 270-171.5G(7))—the category the Townactually applied —contains no such clause,and no conditions at all.The drafters gave one civic category an ancillary allowance and withheld it from the other —Essentially every use in the 22,423 sq ft that the applicant's own architect classifies as Business occupancy —claimed as accessory to an allowable-by-special-permit 2,271 sq ft union hall —is either explicitly or implicitly prohibited,and the code also states,explicitly,that all uses not expressly allowed are prohibited —The idea that 22,423 sq ft of training facility can be accessory to a 2,271 sq ft union hall is also absurd;basic math along with the name itself —the Joint Apprenticeship Training Center — clearly shows thatit's the union hall that's accessory to the prohibited industrial and trades- related training facility. Net result:building this facility in this Low Density Residential Zone,with its more-restrictive applicable IV-T overlay,is prohibited by law. Page 1091 The question of whether this is a permitted use is now formally before the Town.On September 22,2026,at 6pm,the Zoning Board of Appeals takes up my request for interpretation asking that the Town's preliminary determination —that this project (the Training Committee's proposed trade-related,low-impact industrial training facility)is a permitted private club/lodge —be reversed. Allowing it to be built would be against zoning law and undermine my business plan,devalue my investment,harm the plan to make a community landmarkself-sustaining,and scar the Inlet Valley for generations. I've discussed the matter with some neighbors,who've themselves brought it to still more neighbors whom,at the timeof writing this letter,I have yet to have the pleasure of meeting.I'm told the responses to this Apprenticeship Training Facility project have ranged from surprise to horror to opposition,alongside consistent support for my effort to stop it. Apart from the fact that it's prohibited by law,the community simply does not want it.We don't want the clear-cutting and the paving —by their own environmental form,5.25 acres disturbed, more than 4 acres of woods and meadow gone,2.14 acres newly paved or built on,in service of a sprawling,greater than half-an-acre,prohibited by law facility containing multiple prohibited commercial,industrial,and trade-related uses...We don't want any ofthat. This is where we live,and what we do want —whatI have now personally spent years of mylife and considerable resources building toward —is what the Inlet Valley Plan was developed to foster. From an article published in 2024,the Ithaca Times says of Town Supervisor Rod Howe that:“He mentioned that the former Turbacks Restaurant building located at 919 Elmira Road has a new owner and that the Town will be working with them to renovate the building.” That's me.The Town pursuing the grant on my behalf was an amazing anddelightful experience that left an indelible mark on me —it drove home the extent to which the community loves Sunnygables,and it made me feel the weight of the obligation to be a conscientious steward of the landmark property.The fact that we didn't get the grant was a bummer,but hey,life can be like that.It cost me some time,but the grant not appearing hasn't stopped the work. My point is,I took this project on before I had any idea that public funds could become a factor. The grant pursuit was a cool tangent,but public funds never actually did materialize;I've been moving the project forward,independently,toward a result which is exactly in line with the letter and spirit of the IVP. Page 1092 I'm honestly absolutely boggled that it went from “the Town will be working with them to renovate the building”to:hey,now that Stan is 28 months in and has an architect working up plans for rental suites,let's allow a training and industrial facility which the overlay prohibits to be put in next to him to wreck his business plan and undermine his efforts to make Sunnygables self- sustaining. That's about as far from helping me renovate or care for Sunnygables as it gets. Respectfully, Stanley Hiller Sunnygables 919 Elmira Rd Ithaca,NY 14850 cc:C.J.Randall,Director of Planning Marty Moseley,Director of Code Enforcement &Zoning Membersof the Townof Ithaca Town Board SOURCES 1.Townof Ithaca,“Inlet Valley Overlay District.”townithacany.gov/inlet-valley The “Inlet Valley Transition”subzone (IV-T),located immediately south of the IV-C and extending south of the Eddydale Farm Market and Sunnygables property,is intended to serve as a transition and offer more limited commercial opportunities between the more focused IV-C subzone and the low-density residential and agricultural zoning districts at the southern end. 2.Inlet Valley Overlay District law,Town of Ithaca Code Ch.270,Art.XXA,§§270-171.1 to 270-171.6. ecode360.com/41739894 —§270-171.5A(5)(a use not in the tables is not allowed);A(7)(uses are mutually exclusive);A(8)(eachprincipal use considered as if it stands alone);§270-171.5E(7),(8)(trade uses excluded from retail and service;machine shops and building or mechanical trades are not industrial arts studios);§270-171.5F(1)(industrial use:low impact —not allowed in IV-T);§270-171.5G(6),(7)(place of assembly;private club/lodge);§270-171.5I (accessory use table —residential and agricultural accessories only). 3.Inlet Valley Overlay District Use Table Guide,Townof Ithaca.Town ofIthaca documentportal 4.Inlet Valley Overlay District Map,Townof Ithaca.Town of Ithaca document portal 5.ConsultEcon,Inc.and Behan Planning and Design,I-VIP:Inlet Valley Ithaca Plan —Economic Development Feasibility Study and Strategic Plan,prepared for the Townof Ithaca,February 2018.Town of Ithaca document portal Page 1093 10. Ll. 12. 13. Matt Dougherty,“Town of Ithaca Supervisor Reports Progress on TownInitiatives at Council Meeting,”Ithaca Times,May 2,2024 (updated May 7,2024).ithaca.com “State grant sought for revitalizing former Turback's property,”The Ithaca Voice,July 2024. ithacavoice.org Mark H.Anbinder,“Welcome back,Turback's!”,14850.com,June 25,2002.14850.com —~-records the building's earlier use as the Gables Inn. Brian Crandall,“Union training center proposed for Elmira Road in Townof Ithaca,”The Ithaca Voice, September 3,2026.ithacavoice.org “Ithaca town seeks ‘quaint little businesses’in Route 13 corridor rezone,”The Ithaca Voice,January 2023 —contemporaneous coverage of the overlay's adoption.ithacavoice.org Ownership.Deed,Tompkins County Clerk instrument 2026-04397,recorded May 11,2026.Grantor:Rancich Family Limited Partnership.Grantee:Plumbers and Steamfitters Local 81 Joint Apprenticeship Training Committee.Transfer amount $450,000. The December 2025 determination.C.J.Randall,Director of Planning,Town of Ithaca,email of December 23,2025,12:06 PM,copying Director of Code Enforcement &Zoning Marty Moseley —classifying the proposed use under §270-171.5G(7)“based on the details provided.”The details provided:Thomas G. Hayward II (UA Local 81),“Meeting take aways,”email of the same morning,9:38 AM.—Obtained by FOIL request;not publishedonline. Applicant's filings,Planning Board sketch plan review,September1,2026:Full Environmental Assessment Form Part 1 (signed Edward G.Keplinger,July 17,2026);“Plumbers and Steamfitters Local 81 Joint Apprenticeship Training Center —Sketch Plan Review Application Project Summary,”Brian S.Manthey,July 20,2026;drawings by Keplinger Freeman Associates,July 20,2026;architectural set A001/A100/A101/A200.Acreage and disturbance figures cited above (5.25 acres disturbed;2.14 acres new impervious;1.60 acres forested and 2.48 acres meadowlost)are the applicant's own entries at FEAF §§D.1.b, D.2.e and E.1.b.Town of Ithaca document portal Page 1094